42
Legal Representation of the Moiwana Community Members
86(44). The Moiwana community members have been represented domestically, as
well as before the Inter-American System, by the following three organizations:
Moiwana ’86, the Forest Peoples Programme, and Association Moiwana. These
organizations have requested compensation for the costs in which they have incurred
during the instant case’s preparation; on the other hand, they have waived all
attorney fees.58
IX
ARTICLE 5 OF THE AMERICAN CONVENTION
(RIGHT TO HUMANE TREATMENT)
IN RELATION WITH ARTICLE 1(1)
(OBLIGATION TO RESPECT RIGHTS)
Arguments of the representatives
87.
The representatives claimed that the State violated the right to humane
treatment established in Article 5 of the American Convention based on the following
considerations:
a)
the alleged victims have all suffered “substantial, severe and
protracted mental and moral suffering and anguish,” amounting to a violation
of Article 5, which has been proven on the basis of the evidence before the
Court and can be presumed as well due to the nature of the underlying
violations and prevailing state of impunity in the case;
b)
the alleged victims have suffered ongoing and continuous violations of
Article 5 both in their own right as survivors of the massacre and those
denied justice, and by virtue of their status as the next of kin of the “39
persons known to have been murdered at Moiwana Village”;
c)
the violations of Article 5 are directly imputable to Suriname due to its
responsibility for the massacre; its protracted and ongoing refusal to provide
justice to the alleged victims and the resulting state of impunity; and its
failure to cooperate in any way with them in their many attempts to clarify
the facts, to locate and provide proper burials for the remains of their loved
ones and to seek a just closure to their anguish and suffering;
d)
the alleged victims have suffered great anxiety in the knowledge that
their failure to obtain justice for those killed has violated fundamental norms
and obligations of their society and has “invited the wrath of the spirits of the
dead,” which may also inflict suffering upon their children and future
generations;
testimony of Andre Ajintoena delivered before the Inter-American Court on September 9, 2004; and
testimony of Erwin Willemdam delivered before the Inter-American Court on September 9, 2004.
58
Cf. Expense receipts (case file on preliminary objections and possible merits, reparations and
costs, vol. IV, pp. 903 and 924 – 994).