B. CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ................................................................................................... 76
B.1. Alleged violation of the right to life, personal integrity, and not to be forcibly displaced of
members of the Cacarica communities owing to bombings during Operation Genesis .................... 79
B.2. Alleged responsibility of the State in the paramilitary incursions in the Cacarica river basin and,
consequently, in the incursion that resulted in an alleged violation of the rights to life and to personal
integrity of Marino López, which presumably led to the forced displacement of members of the
Cacarica communities, in alleged violation of the rights to personal integrity and not to be displaced.85
IX.2. CONDITIONS OF DISPLACEMENT, AND RETURN OF MEMBERS OF THE CACARICA
COMMUNITIES FOLLOWING THE EVENTS OF FEBRUARY 1997 (Articles 5(1), 22, 17, 19, 1(1)
and 2 of the Convention) .......................................................................................................100
A. ARGUMENTS OF THE COMMISSION AND OF THE PARTIES ........................................................................ 100
B. CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ................................................................................................. 106
B.1.
B.2.
B.3.
B.4.
Rights not to be displaced and to personal integrity ................................................ 107
Right to protection of the family .............................................................................. 108
Rights of children and adolescents ........................................................................... 109
Other alleged violations ........................................................................................... 110
IX.3. DISPOSSESSION AND EXPLOITATION OF THE TERRITORIES OF THE AFRO-DESCENDANT
COMMUNITIES OF THE CACARICA (Artículo 21 of the Convention) ........................................112
A. ARGUMENTS OF THE COMMISSION AND OF THE PARTIES ........................................................................ 112
B. CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ................................................................................................. 113
B.1. The harm to the individual and collective property of the communities of the Cacarica River
basin ................................................................................................................................ 113
B.2. The illegal exploitation of the territories of the Community Council of the Communities of the
Cacarica River basin ........................................................................................................... 116
IX.4 CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS AND PROCEEDINGS AND OTHER PROCEDURES (Articles 8
and 25 of the Convention) .....................................................................................................117
A. ARGUMENTS OF THE COMMISSION AND OF THE PARTIES ........................................................................ 117
B. CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ................................................................................................. 119
B.1. Considerations on due diligence and logical lines of investigation. ...................................... 120
B.2. Considerations on the reasonable time. .......................................................................... 127
B.3. Considerations on the applications for amparo concerning collective ownership ................... 128
X. REPARATIONS (Application of Article 63(1) of the American Convention) .........................130
A. INJURED PARTY ...................................................................................................................... 131
A.1. Arguments of the Commission and of the parties ............................................................. 131
A.2. Considerations of the Court ........................................................................................... 133
B. OBLIGATION TO INVESTIGATE ...................................................................................................... 137
B.1. Arguments of the Commission and of the parties ............................................................. 137
B.2. Considerations of the Court ........................................................................................... 137
C. MEASURES OF SATISFACTION, REHABILITATION AND RESTITUTION ............................................................ 138
C.1. Measures of satisfaction ............................................................................................... 138
C.2. Measures of rehabilitation ............................................................................................. 140
C.3. Measures of restitution ................................................................................................. 141
D. COMPENSATION ..................................................................................................................... 143
D.1. Arguments of the Commission and of the parties ............................................................. 143
D.2. Considerations of the Court .......................................................................................... 146
E. COSTS AND EXPENSES .............................................................................................................. 148
F. METHOD OF COMPLYING WITH THE PAYMENTS ORDERED ........................................................................ 149
X. OPERATIVE PARAGRAPHS ..................................................................................................149
3