199. Accordingly, of the group of workers present in Hacienda Brasil Verde at the time of
the April 1997 inspection, when delivering this judgment, the Court has sufficient and reliable
probative elements to prove the status of presumed victims of alleged violations of the right
to judicial guarantees and protection of the following 43 workers: 1. Antônio Alves de
Souza;218 2. Antônio Bispo dos Santos;219 3. Antônio da Silva Nascimento;220 4. Antônio
Pereira da Silva;221 5. Antônio Renato Barros;222 6. Benigno Rodrigues da Silva;223 7. Carlos
Alberto Albino da Conceição;224 8. Cassimiro Neto Souza Maia;225 9. Dijalma Santos
Batista;226 10. Edi Souza de Silva;227 11. Edmilson Fernandes dos Santos;228 12. Edson
Pocidônio da Silva;229 13. Irineu Inácio da Silva;230 14. Geraldo Hilário de Almeida;231 15.
João de Deus dos Reis Salvino;232 16. João Germano da Silva;233 17. João Pereira Marinho;234
18. Joaquim Francisco Xavier;235 19. José Astrogildo Damascena;236 20. José Carlos Alves
dos Santos;237 21. José Fernando da Silva Filho;238 22. José Francisco de Lima;239 23. José
Lima; 13. Raimundo Nonato in relation to Raimundo Nonato da Silva, 14. Sebastião Rodrigues in relation to
Sebastião Rodrigues da Silva.
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1255); RE (evidence file, folio 1752); TC (evidence file, folio 1753), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
218
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1257); RE (evidence file, folio 1756); TC (evidence file, folio 1757), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
219
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1257); RE (evidence file, folio 1754); TC (evidence file, folio 1755), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
220
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1254); VF (evidence file, folio 1226); RE (evidence file, folio 1758); TC (evidence file,
folio 1759), and PP (evidence file, folio 600).
221
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1255); RE (evidence file, folio 1760); TC (evidence file, folio 1761), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
222
223
Cf. RE (evidence file, folio 1738) and PP (evidence file, folio 600).
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1256); RE (evidence file, folio 1762); TC (evidence file, folio 1763), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
224
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1257); RE (evidence file, folio 1764); TC (evidence file, folio 1765), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
225
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1257); RE (evidence file, folio 1766); TC (evidence file, folio 1767), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
226
227
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1254).
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1257); RE (evidence file, folio 1768); TC (evidence file, folio 1769), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
228
Who also appears as Edson Possidonio. Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1255); RE (evidence file, folio 1770); TC
(evidence file, folio 1771), and PP (evidence file, folio 600).
229
230
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1255).
231
Cf. RE (evidence file, folio 1740), and PP (evidence file, folio 600).
232
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1256).
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1254); RE (evidence file, folio 1772); TC (evidence file, folio 1773), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
233
Cf. VF (evidence file, folio 1230); RE (evidence file, folio 1742); TC (evidence file, folio 1743), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
234
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1257); RE (evidence file, folio 1774); TC (evidence file, folio 1775), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
235
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1257); RE (evidence file, folio 1776); TC (evidence file, folio 1777), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
236
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1256); RE (evidence file, folio 1778); TC (evidence file, folio 1779), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
237
238
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1254).
Cf. RI (evidence file, folio 1254); RE (evidence file, folio 1780); TC (evidence file, folio 1781), and PP (evidence
file, folio 600).
239
48