SIC-10, a repressive structure of the police that arose from the Criminal Investigations Service
(SIC) began to function and it clandestinely endeavored to “repress and eliminate” members
of “Alfaro Vive Carajo” and other organizations.24
39. During the presidency of Rodrigo Borja (1988-1992), although there was a greater
respect for political rights and freedom of expression, the security and repressive policies
continued. During this period, police and Armed Forces groups accused of human rights
violations were not dismantled nor were measures adopted with regard to those responsible
for the violations committed during the government of Febres Cordero.25
40. According to the Report of the Truth Commission, there were 17 forced disappearances
from 1985 to 2004 in Ecuador.26 Of the 17, three were known as members of “Alfaro Vive
Carajo” and one was associated with “Montoneras Patria Libre.” In the cases known to the
Truth Commission, the forced disappearances began with the detention of the victims by State
agents who “abused their authority and used unjustified and excessive force” in the context
of repressive or routine operations.27 The Truth Commission also indicated that the modus
operandi was characterized by a pact of silence among the members of the institutions of the
public forces who participated in the human rights violations and a similar pact among other
members who had or could have information, as well as by the destruction of incriminating
records and documents, misinformation and a public denial of the events denounced by family
members and public opinion.28
41. Other sources also refer to the statistics on forced disappearances in Ecuador. Thus,
according to the Inter-American Commission’s “Report on the Situation of Human Rights in
Ecuador” of 1997, from 1985 to 1995, there were between 25 and 30 forced
disappearances.”29 For its part, the UN Working Group on Forced and Involuntary
Disappearances informed on 17 cases of disappearances in Ecuador between 1985 and 1992,
and indicated that the majority of the cases referred to persons who had been detained by
members of the SIC of the National Police.30
responsibility of this policy of the elimination of the subversion and of the alleged subversives falls on the former
President of the Republic, León Febres Cordero and his Ministers of Government and Defense” (evidence file, folios
2207 to 2236).
Cf. Executive Summary. Sin Verdad no hay Justicia. Final Report of the Truth Commission of Ecuador, 2010
(evidence file, folio 2582).
24
The Report of the Truth Commission of Ecuador states: “Since 1988 to date, successive governments in which
in some of them many of the security doctrines and policies remained unchanged, while others only changed in name and
form. Although the extent of human rights violations has diminished in terms of State policy, the repressive basis of many
of the practices remained in different periods without substantial change with respect to the doctrine of security and some
of the practices, such as torture and the undue use of force.” Cf. Executive Summary. Sin Verdad no hay Justicia. Final
Report of the Truth Commission of Ecuador, 2010 (evidence file, folio 2514).
25
26
Cf. Executive Summary. Sin Verdad no hay Justicia. Final Report of the Truth Commission of Ecuador, 2010
(evidence file, folios 2466 and 2466).
Cf. Executive Summary. Sin Verdad no hay Justicia. Final Report of the Truth Commission of Ecuador, 2010
(evidence file, folio 2467).
27
Cf. Executive Summary. Sin Verdad no hay Justicia. Final Report of the Truth Commission of Ecuador, 2010
(evidence file, folio 2467).
28
Cf. Inter-American Commission on Human Rights. Report on the Situation of Human Rights in Ecuador,
OEA/Ser.L/V/II.96, Doc.10 rev. 1, April 24, 1997, Chapter IV: RIGHT TO LIFE, E. Complaints on disappearances.
Available at: http://www.cidh.org/countryrep/ecuador-sp/Capitulo%204.htm
29
Cf. United Nations, Economic and Social Council, Report of the Working Group on Forced and Involuntary
Disappearances, UN Doc. E/CN.4/1995/36, December 21, 1994, para. 145.
30
11