30 76. From examining the documents, the statements of the witnesses, the report of the expert and the evidence provided by the Inter-American Commission during the proceedings, the Court considers that the following facts have been proved: a) Baruch Ivcher Bronstein, of Israeli origin, was granted Peruvian nationality through “Supreme Resolution” No. 0649/RE of November 27, 1984, issued by the President of the Republic of Peru and also signed by the President of the Council of Ministers and the Minister for Foreign Affairs 14; b) on December 6, 1984, Mr. Ivcher Bronstein renounced his Israeli nationality15; c) on December 7, 1984, the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Peru issued Mr. Ivcher nationality title No. 004644 16; d) Mr. Ivcher exercised rights that arise from Peruvian nationality during approximately 13 years17; e) Peruvian legislation in force in 1997 established that, it was necessary to be a Peruvian national in order to own companies with licenses for television channels in Peru18; f) in 1986, Mr. Ivcher was the majority shareholder in the Company, which operated Peruvian television’s Channel 219. 14 Cf. “Supreme Order” No. 0649/RE issued on November 27, 1984; Sworn declaration by Luis Pércovich Roca of November 24, 1997; testimony of July Sotelo Casanova before the Inter-American Court on November 20, 2000; and testimony of Luis Pércovich Roca before the Inter-American Court on November 20, 2000. 15 Cf. Deed renouncing Israeli nationality signed by Baruch Ivcher Bronstein, whose testimony was notarized by Máximo Luis Vargas H., under No. K.8489 on December 6, 1984; Sworn declaration by Luis Pércovich Roca of November 24, 1997; testimony of July Sotelo before the Inter-American Court on November 20, 2000; and testimony of Luis Pércovich Roca before the Inter-American Court on November 20, 2000. 16 Cf. Peruvian nationality title No. 004644, issued on December 7, 1984 by the Department of Nationalization of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Peru, in favor of Baruch Ivcher Bronstein; sworn declaration by Luis Pércovich Roca of November 24, 1997; “Directorial Order” No. 11797-IN-050100000000, of July 11, 1997, published in the official gazette, El Peruano, entitled “Peruvian nationality title annulled”; testimony of July Sotelo Casanova before the Inter-American Court on November 20, 2000; testimony of Luis Pércovich Roca before the Inter-American Court on November 20, 2000. 17 Cf. Notarized document No. KR 80397, attesting to the deed increasing the capital and partially modifying the statutes of Compañía Latinoamericana de Radiodifusión S.A., of January 27, 1986; notarized document No. 189-190, of September 14, 1998, in which the capital was increased, the statutes were partially modified and Mr. Ivcher became chairman of the board of Productos Paraíso del Peru; record of share transfer (transferencia de acciones por anticipa de legitima) of August 15, 1997, by which Mr. and Mrs. Ivcher ceded their shares to their four daughters; Certified copy No. 272-97, issued by the notary, Cesar Carpio, corresponding to the minutes of the extraordinary meeting of the shareholders of Compañía Latinoamericana de Radiodifusión of September 26, 1997; testimony of July Sotelo Casanova before the Inter-American Court, on November 20, 2000; and testimony of Luis Pércovich Roca before the Inter-American Court, on November 20, 2000. 18 Cf. Petition for habeas corpus filed on July 11, 1997, by Samuel and Mendel Winter Zuzunaga, before the First Temporary Commercial Public Law Court; and expert report of Samuel Abad Yupanqui before the Inter-American Court on November 20, 2000. 19 Cf. Notarized document No. KR 80397, of the deed increasing the capital and partially modifying the statutes of Compañía Latinoamericana de Radiodifusión S.A., of January 27, 1986; testimony of Luis