to bathrooms (supra para. 74); therefore, it finds that there was a situation of overcrowding
contrary to the personal integrity of the persons detained in the PTJ.
B.6. The alleged violation of the personal integrity of María Fernanda Peña
Gallardo
198. With regard to María Fernanda Peña Gallardo, the Court considers that it is not possible to
find a direct link between the State’s actions and her suicide. No evidence was presented that
proved the use of psychological torture against her, or coercion and threats by members of the
Prosecution Service and the Police. It has merely been proved that Ms. Peña Gallardo was among
the suspects in the case and that she had been summoned to provide an informative statement
before the Public Prosecution Service on June 6, 2002.291
199. Nevertheless, the Court has understood that it is appropriate to presume the violation of the
right to personal integrity applying a iuris tantum presumption with regard to family members,
such as mothers and fathers, daughters and sons, spouses and permanent companions, and
siblings of victims of certain human rights violations, provided this responds to the particular
circumstances of the case.292 It has declared the violation of this right owing to the suffering
derived from the acts perpetrated against their loved ones.293
200. In the instant case, according to Patricia Gallardo’s sworn statement, her daughter, María
Fernanda, was present during the raid of her home, so that she witnessed the violence to which
the police subjected her mother. This situation could have caused María Fernanda Peña Gallardo
anguish, stress and pain, which could have had an impact on her emotional state.
201. Consequently, the Court concludes that the State is responsible for the violation of Article
5(1) of the American Convention, in relation to Article 1(1) of this instrument, to the detriment of
María Fernanda Peña Gallardo.
B.7. Conclusions
202. Based on all the above, the Court finds the Plurinational State of Bolivia responsible for the
violation of personal integrity recognized in Article 5(1) and 5(2) of the American Convention, in
relation to the general obligation established in Article 1(1) of this instrument, owing to the acts
of torture committed against Víctor Manuel Boggiano Bruzzón, Carlos Enrique Castro Ramírez,
Eladio Cruz Añez, F.E.P.M. and Raúl Oswaldo Lulleman Gutiérrez.
203. Similarly, based on acts of sexual torture, it is responsible for the violation of Article 5(1)
and 5(2) in relation to Article 1(1) of the American Convention and Article 7(a) of the InterAmerican Convention for the Prevention, Punishment and Eradication of Violence against Women
(Convention of Belém do Pará), to the detriment of F.E.P.M., Patricia Gallardo Ardúz, Norma Lupe
Alarcón de Valencia, Claudia Valencia Alarcón, Mercedes Valencia Chuquimia, Victoria Gutiérrez,
Jenny Paola Lulleman and Julia Mamanu Mamani.
Cf. Public Prosecution Service, Record of suspension of hearing on informative statement of June 6, 2002
(evidence file, folio 838).
291
Cf. Case of Blake v. Guatemala. Merits. Judgment of January 24, 1998. Series C No. 36, para. 114, and Case
of Movilla Galarcio et al. v. Colombia, supra, para. 174.
292
293
Cf. Case of Bámaca Velásquez v. Guatemala. Merits. Judgment of November 25, 2000. Series C No. 70, paras.
162 and 163, and Case of Vera Rojas et al. v. Chile. Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and costs. Judgment
of October 1, 2021. Series C No. 439, para. 153.
58
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents