when I asked to see the forensic physician because I was bleeding heavily, he refused to help
me.114
92.
Meanwhile, Claudia Valencia Alarcón stated:
It was on 18 [December] when, at 3:00 a.m., I saw a man approaching my house and,
seconds later, more than 100 police officers entered; then, I heard screams and cries from
my parents. When I was able to go down to see what was happening, I saw my two younger
brothers lying on the ground; then I saw how they put a rifle between my mother’s buttocks;
she was bleeding; then, they began to beat me; they put a nylon bag over my head; they
brought my son to me and they undressed me; I heard my 11-year old brother crying and,
that was the day they kidnapped him; we had no news of him; in the middle of all this, they
began to speak to my brother who was trembling, who was afraid, and the police officers
were so ignorant that they did not even realize that my brother was foaming at the mouth;
my brother suffered from epilepsy and he was having a seizure; they had no compassion
[…]. They beat us for 3 hours, they groped us; I felt hands touching my body […].
The ill-treatment continued in the PTJ; that day, they made us sleep in dark, cold and humid
cells; without a right to anything; we didn’t have a bathroom; the following day, we were
taken to the Ministry of the Interior to be presented to the media; we were all taken, even
the young children, who were the children of the defendants present in this trial; we were
shown to the people; they allowed us to be insulted and even spat on; all out statements
were taken under threat and torture; we were obliged to speak; every day they took us out
of the cells to touch our bodies; they put their fingers in our mouths and vaginas in front of
all the men; they did this four times a day; we were kept in solitary confinement; we were
allowed to go to the bathroom only two minutes each day; I saw how [F.E.P.M] was bleeding
heavily because she had been pregnant and they made her lose her baby; no one defended
us; when we arrived at the different prisons, we were kept in solitary confinement; I was
unable to communicate with my father for 3 months; they told me that he was dying; I
could not see my son; they took him away from me.115
93. In addition, several of the defense lawyers argued that the raids, the ill-treatment and acts
of torture committed during them, and the detentions were unlawful before the court during the
oral proceedings116 and in their final oral arguments.117 Similarly, during the interrogation of the
Statement by F.E.P.M. during the oral proceedings before El Alto Second Sentencing Court, January 17, 2003
(evidence file, folios 65 and 66).
114
Statement by Claudia Valencia Alarcón in the oral proceedings before the El Alto Second Sentencing Court,
January 21, 2003 (evidence file, folio 84).
115
Statement by Blas Valencia’s co-sponsoring lawyers in the oral proceedings before the El Alto Second Sentencing
Court, January 29, 2003 (evidence file, folio 95); statement by Patricia Gallardo’s lawyer in the oral proceedings
before the El Alto Second Sentencing Court, January 29, 2003 (evidence file, folio 96); statement by the Norma Alarcón
de Valencia’s co-sponsoring lawyer before the El Alto Second Sentencing Court, January 29, 2003 (evidence file, folio
99); statement by Raul and Oswaldo Lulleman’s lawyer before the El Alto Second Sentencing Court, January 29, 2003
(evidence file, folios 99 and 100); statement by F.E.P.M.’s lawyer before the El Alto Second Sentencing Court, January
29, 2003 (evidence file, folio 101); statement by Elacio Peña Córdova’s lawyer before the El Alto Second Sentencing
Court, January 29, 2003 (evidence file, folio 104); statement by Carlos Enrique Castro’s lawyer before the El Alto
Second Sentencing Court, January 29, 2003 (evidence file, ‘folio 104).
116
117
Patricia Gallardo Ardúz’s lawyer referred to the unlawful nature of the raids (final oral arguments presented
before the El Alto Second Sentencing Court on May 13, 2003, evidence file folio 485); Mercedes Valencia Chuquimia’s
lawyer stated that his client’s son had been beaten and tortured (final oral arguments presented before the El Alto
Second Sentencing Court on May 14, 2003, evidence file, folios 492 and 493); similarly, the lawyer for Oswaldo
Lulleman Antezana and Raul Oswaldo Lulleman Gutiérrez stated that the acts of violence had been reported to the
Ombudsman and to the Human Rights Committee of the Chamber of Deputies. He also denounced the abuse suffered
by being presented to the media as criminals (final oral arguments presented before the El Alto Second Sentencing
Court on May 14, 2003, evidence file, folio 494). Also, F.E.P.M.’s lawyer reiterated the ill-treatment that his client had
suffered during the raid and subsequent detention (final oral arguments presented before the El Alto Second
Sentencing Court on May 14, 2003, evidence file, folios 497 and 498). The lawyer for Elacio Peña Córdova and Carlos
Enrique Castro also referred to the unlawful nature of the raid and stated that his clients’ statements had been
28