54 was the son of María Libia Carmona de Ortiz and Jesús María Ortiz65 and had two sisters, Rosángela and Gudiela del Carmen Ortiz Carmona. His children are Omar Alveiro Ortiz Calle, Juan Carlos Ortiz Callo, Deisy Tatiana Ortiz Calle, Johan Daniel Ortiz Calle and Cristian de Jesús Calle. His death had a profound emotional effect on his family. 125(60) Fabio Antonio Zuleta Zabala worked on Omar de Jesús Ortiz Carmona’s farm and was 54 years of age at the time of his death. He lived with María Graciela Cossio Jaramillo,66 who had been his permanent companion for more than ten years, and his children, Carlos Adrián, Yeison Andrés and Juan Felipe Zuleta Cossio.67 He was the son of María Magdalena Zabala68 and Roberto Zuleta69 and his siblings are Margarita, Araccelly, Rodrigo and Orlando, all with the last names Zuleta Zabala. He also had a half-sister by his mother, named Celia Monsalve Zabala. He helped his parents financially, in addition to providing for his children and his companion. As a result of the death of Fabio Antonio Zuleta Zabala, his permanent companion lost the family’s financial support, so that the children had to go to Medellín to live with Celia Monsalve Zabala, half-sister of the alleged victim, who assumed their care. The whole family was severely affected by the death of Fabio Antonio; it broke up the family, and they now live in different places. 125(61) Then, the same day, on the La Planta farm, the armed group murdered Arnulfo Sánchez Álvarez, who was an elderly man. He owned land, where he grew fruit trees and had cattle.70 His wife was Teresa del Niño Jesús Álvarez Palacio71 and they had a daughter named Vilma Ester Sánchez Álvarez.72 125(62) Then the paramilitary group went by foot to the municipal district of El Aro, which was six hours from Puerto Valdivia. 65 Cf. baptism certificate of Johan Daniel Ortiz Calle (file of attachments to the application, tome I, folios 0474 to 0478). 66 Cf. birth certificate of María Graciela Cossio Jaramillo (file of attachments to the application, tome I, folio 0516); and birth certificate of Juan Felipe Zuleta Cossio (file of attachments to the application, tome I, folio 518). 67 Cf. birth certificate of Juan Felipe Zuleta Cossio (file of attachments to the application, tome I, folio 518); birth certificate of Carlos Adrián Zuleta Cossio (file of attachments to the application, tome I, folio 520); and birth certificate of Yeison Andrés Zuleta Cossio (file of attachments to the application, tome I, folio 522). 68 Cf. birth certificate of Fabio Antonio Zuleta Zabala (file of attachments to the application, tome I, folio 513); and identity card of María Magdalena Zabala (file of attachments to the application, tome I, folio 492). 69 Cf. birth certificate of Fabio Antonio Zuleta Zabala (file of attachments to the application, tome I, folio 513). 70 Cf. testimony given by Amado de Jesús Jaramillo Cano on August 30, 2000 before the Valdivia Municipal Civil and Criminal Court (file of attachments to the application, tome II, Appendix C34, folio 917). 71 Cf. marriage certificate of Arnulfo Sánchez Álvarez and Teresa del Niño Jesús Álvarez Placio (file of documents presented by the representatives of the alleged victims on September 23, 2005, folio 5613). 72 Cf. baptism certificate of Vilma Ester Sánchez Álvarez (file of documents presented by the representatives of the alleged victims on September 23, 2005, folio 5618).