B.2.6. Fifth motion for review ...................................................................... 98
B.2.7. Conclusion ...................................................................................... 99
B.3. Regarding Jorge Martinez Meléndez (Group 4)......................................... 99
B.3.1. Cassation appeals ............................................................................ 99
B.3.2. Motion for review ........................................................................... 106
B.3.3. Conclusion .................................................................................... 107
B.4. Regarding Miguel Mora Calvo (Group 7) ............................................... 107
B.4.1. Appeal in cassation......................................................................... 107
B.4.2. Motions for review .......................................................................... 108
B.4.3. Conclusion .................................................................................... 112
VIII.II ......................................................................................................... 112
RIGHT TO PERSONAL LIBERTY .................................................................... 112
(ARTICLE 7 OF THE AMERICAN CONVENTION) ............................................ 112
A. Arguments of the parties and the Commission ............................................................................... 112
B. Considerations of the Court ............................................................................................................. 113
B.1. Articles 7(1), 7(2), 7(3) and 7(5) of the Convention............................... 114
B.2. Article 7(6) of the Convention ............................................................. 119
VIII.III........................................................................................................ 120
RIGHT TO JUDICIAL GUARANTEES (ARTICLES 8(1) AND 8(2) OF THE
CONVENTION, IN RELATION TO ARTICLE 1(1) THEREOF) ........................... 120
A. Right to be heard by a competent, independent and impartial judge ................................................. 120
A.1. Arguments of the Commission and the parties ...................................... 120
A.2. Considerations of the Court ................................................................ 121
A.2.1 Situation of Jorge Martínez Meléndez (Group 4) ................................... 123
A.2.2. Situation of Rafael Rojas Madrigal (Group 2) ...................................... 127
A.2.3. Situation of Miguel Mora Calvo (Group 7) ........................................... 130
B. Right to be tried within a reasonable time........................................................................................... 130
B.1. Arguments of the parties ................................................................... 130
B.2. Considerations of the Court ................................................................ 131
C. Alleged violation of the right to defense .............................................................................................. 133
C.1. Arguments of the Commission and the parties ...................................... 133
C.2. Considerations of the Court ................................................................ 134
C.2.1. Situation of Jorge Martínez Meléndez (Group 4) ......................................................................... 135
C.2.1.1. Alleged violation of the right to hear and present evidence ................ 135
C.2.1.2. Alleged denial of the right to introduce evidence .............................. 137
C.2.1.3. Alleged violation of the right to read the judgment ........................... 137
C.2.2. Situation of Luis Archbold Jay and Enrique Archbold Jay (Group 3) ........ 138
C.2.3. Situation of Rafael Rojas Madrigal (Group 2) ...................................... 138
D. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................... 138
VIII.IV ........................................................................................................ 139
RIGHT TO PERSONAL INTEGRITY ................................................................ 139
(ARTICLE 5 OF THE CONVENTION) .............................................................. 139
A. Arguments of the Commission and the parties ............................................................................... 139
B. Considerations of the Court ............................................................................................................. 139
C. Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 141
IX ................................................................................................................ 141
REPARATIONS ............................................................................................. 141
A. Injured party .................................................................................................................................... 142
B. Comprehensive measures of reparation .......................................................................................... 142
B.1. Satisfaction ...................................................................................... 142
B.1.1 Publication of the judgment .............................................................. 142
C. Other measures requested.................................................................................................................... 143
D. Compensation................................................................................................................................... 143
D.1. Non-pecuniary damage...................................................................... 143
4