13 detainee was taken “with his hands bound to prevent him escaping, and with a hood on because that was 47 standard procedure.” Similarly, Porfirio Osorio Rivera and Santa Fe Gaytán Calderón claim to have seen Jeremías Osorio for the last time on the morning of April 30, 1991, his hands tied and a hood covering his face, as he was being taken by the Army patrol toward the Cajatambo Countersubversive 48 Base. 55. Ms. Juana Rivera Lozano was standing in front of the Nunumia community center as her son was forced to accompany the Army patrol. Seeing the conditions in which he was being taken and 49 hearing comments telling her to say goodbye to Jeremías Osorio, she broke down and fainted. Aquiles Román Atencio, a villager who also witnessed the events of the morning of April 29, 1991, said he was “aware that the people of Nunumia had issued a certificate of good conduct on behalf of Jeremías Osorio 50 Rivera, but there were comments that as a result, [Lt. Juan Carlos Tello] had threatened them.” 56. Following that incident, Porfirio Osorio was told by three of the four villagers who accompanied the Army patrol that they had “accompanied [his] brother as far as the place known as Shapil, where the lieutenant had told them to carry on toward Astobamba, while they headed for Cajatambo with his brother.” Mr. Porfirio Osorio stated that some villagers heard shouts coming from the Nunumia schoolhouse where his brother was being held, and that they also reported that his face had been injured. Porfirio Osorio reported that the civilians who accompanied the soldiers on April 30 remarked that Jeremías Osorio was limping and was forced to walk, and that the soldiers provided him 51 with no food. 57. On the morning of May 1, 1991, the victim’s siblings Porfirio and Silvia Osorio Rivera went to the Cajatambo Countersubversive Base, where they were told by a noncommissioned officer by the name of Mamani that Lt. Juan Carlos Tello was not present, and that no detainees had been brought 52 there. On May 2, Mr. Porfirio Osorio returned to the Cajatambo Base, where Lt. Juan Carlos Tello informed him that Jeremías Osorio had been released the previous day. When he insisted on additional information on his brother’s whereabouts, he was shown, by the officer in question, a copy of a radio 53 message purportedly reporting Jeremías Osorio’s release. 58. In the afternoon of May 2, 1991, Mr. Porfirio Osorio went to the homestead where his brother lived in Cochas-Paca, but the victim’s companion and children told him they had not seen him. On 54 May 3, 1991, Jeremías Osorio’s family finally searched for him in likely places. Given the lack of 47 Annex 25: Judgment of December 17, 2008, issued by the National Criminal Chamber in the criminal prosecution of Juan Carlos César Tello Delgado, case file No. 554-07, section 2, “Statement of the Accused.” Annex 33: Document titled “Confrontation of the suspect, Andrés López Cárdenas, with the complainant, Porfirio Osorio Rivera” before the Provincial Mixed Court of Cajatambo, August 28, 1991, in which Juan Carlos César Tello states that “I did indeed order a balaclava to placed on his head, as a procedure to be followed when detainees are transferred.” 48 Annex 32: Preventive statement of Porfirio Osorio Rivera, given on July 7, 2006, to the Mixed Court of Cajatambo, p. 1. Annex 22: Witness statement of Santa Fe Gaytán Calderón, given on July 7, 2006, to the Mixed Court of Cajatambo, case file No. 077-2005-P, p. 2. 49 Annex 25: Judgment of December 17, 2008, issued by the National Criminal Chamber in the criminal prosecution of Juan Carlos César Tello Delgado, case file No. 554-07, section 5, “During the Oral Proceedings,” No. 1. Annex 20: Investigation statement of Porfirio Osorio Rivera, given on October 18, 2004, to the Specialized Provincial Prosecutor’s office. 50 Annex 25: Judgment of December 17, 2008, issued by the National Criminal Chamber in the criminal prosecution of Juan Carlos César Tello Delgado, case file No. 554-07, section 5, “During the Oral Proceedings,” No. 2. 51 Annex 32: Preventive statement of Porfirio Osorio Rivera, given on July 7, 2006, to the Mixed Court of Cajatambo, pp. 52 Annex 32: Preventive statement of Porfirio Osorio Rivera, given on July 7, 2006, to the Mixed Court of Cajatambo, p. 3. 4 to 6. 53 Annex 25: Judgment of December 17, 2008, issued by the National Criminal Chamber in the criminal prosecution of Juan Carlos César Tello Delgado, case file No. 554-07, section 5, “During the Oral Proceedings,” No. 2. 54 Annex 32: Preventive statement of Porfirio Osorio Rivera, given on July 7, 2006, to the Mixed Court of Cajatambo, p. 3. Annex 22: Witness statement of Santa Fe Gaytán Calderón, given on July 7, 2006, to the Mixed Court of Cajatambo, p. 2, in which she says that on May 2, 1991, “my brother-in-law arrived home and told me my partner had been released; but when he didn’t appear, he searched everywhere where he might have been until we gave up…”