142
by US$4,000.00 (four thousand United States dollars) in favor of the three mothers,
because they where the ones that had to seek justice; (iv) to increase the resulting
amount by US$1,000.00 (one thousand United States dollars) in favor of Adrián
Herrera Monreal, Claudia Ivonne, and Daniel Ramos Monárrez; Ramón Antonio Aragón
Monárrez, and Claudia Dayana, Itzel Arely, and Paola Alexandra Bermúdez Ramos
owing to the acts of harassment they suffered, and (iv) to increase the resulting
amount by US$3,000.00 (three thousand United States dollars) in favor of Benita
Ramos Salgado, owing to the acts of harassment she suffered.
585. Furthermore, even though the representatives did not request it, the Tribunal
deems it appropriate to order the State to compensate Mss. Herrera, Ramos and
González, for the failure to ensure their rights to life, personal integrity and personal
liberty. To establish the corresponding amount, the Court bears in mind its
jurisprudence in similar cases,549 the context in which the facts occurred, the age of
the victims and the consequent special obligations of the State for the protection of the
child, and the gender-based violence that the three victims suffered. Accordingly, it
establishes, in equity, the sum of US$38,000.00 (thirty-eight thousand United States
dollars) in favor of Claudia Ivette González and US$40,000.00 (forty thousand United
States dollars) for each of the minors, Esmeralda Herrera Monreal and Laura Berenice
Ramos Monárrez. These amounts shall be distributed in accordance with the current
laws on inheritance in the state of Chihuahua, Mexico.
586.
The State shall therefore deliver the following amounts:
Victim
Esmeralda Herrera Monreal
Irma Monreal Jaime
Benigno Herrera Monreal
Adrián Herrera Monreal
Juan Antonio Herrera Monreal
Cecilia Herrera Monreal
Zulema Montijo Monreal
Erick Montijo Monreal
Juana Ballín Castro
Claudia Ivette González
Irma Josefina González Rodríguez
Mayela Banda González
Gema Iris González
Karla Arizbeth Hernández Banda
Jacqueline Hernández
Carlos Hernández Llamas
Laura Berenice Ramos Monárrez
Benita Monárrez Salgado
Claudia Ivonne Ramos Monárrez
Daniel Ramos Monárrez
Ramón Antonio Aragón Monárrez
Claudia Dayana Bermúdez Ramos
Itzel Arely Bermúdez Ramos
Paola Alexandra Bermúdez Ramos
Atziri Geraldine Bermúdez Ramos
549
Relationship
Mother
Brother
Brother
Brother
Sister
Sister
Brother
Sister-in-law
Mother
Sister
Sister
Niece
Niece
Brother-in-law
Mother
Sister
Brother
Brother
Niece
Niece
Niece
Niece
Amount
US$40,000.00
US$15,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$12,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$38,000.00
US$15,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$11,000.00
US$40,000.00
US$18,000.00
US$12,000.00
US$12,000.00
US$12,000.00
US$12,000.00
US$12,000.00
US$12,000.00
US$12,000.00
Cf. Case of the “Mapiripán Massacre” v. Colombia, supra note 252, para. 288; Case of Heliodoro
Portugal v. Panamá, supra note 297, para. 239, and Case of Kawas Fernández v. Honduras, supra note 190,
para. 184.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents