24 THE COURT By fours votes to one 1. Decides that the Republic of Colombia has violated, to the detriment of Isidro Caballero-Delgado and María del Carmen Santana the rights to personal liberty and to life contained in Articles 7 and 4, read in conjunction with Article 1(1) of the American Convention on Human Rights. Judge Nieto-Navia dissenting. By four votes to one 2. Decides that the Republic of Colombia has not violated the right to humane treatment contained in Article 5 of the American Convention on Human Rights. Judge Pacheco-Gómez dissenting Unanimously 3. Decides that the Republic of Colombia has not violated Articles 2, 8, and 25 of the American Convention on Human Rights, relative to the duty to adopt measures to give effect to the rights and freedoms ensured by the Convention, right to a fair trial, and the judicial protection of rights. Unanimously 4. Decides that the Republic of Colombia has not violated Articles 51(2) and 44 of the American Convention on Human Rights. Unanimously 5. Decides that the Republic of Colombia is obligated to continue judicial proceedings into the disappearance and presumed death of the persons named and to extend punishment in accordance with internal law. By four votes to one