5
At any stage of the proceedings involving cases of extreme gravity and urgency, and
when necessary to avoid irreparable damage to persons, the Court may, at the request
of a party or on its own motion, order such provisional measures as it deems pertinent,
pursuant to Article 63(2) of the Convention;
4.
That under international human rights law, provisional measures are not only
precautionary, in the sense of preserving a juridical situation; they are also
safeguards inasmuch as they protect human rights. When the requisite basic
conditions of extreme gravity and urgency are present and when necessary to
prevent irreparable harm to persons, provisional measures become a true
jurisdictional guarantee that is preventive in nature;
5.
That in requesting provisional measures to protect the freedom of expression
of “journalist Mauricio Herrera Ulloa and the newspaper La Nación”, represented by
Fernán Vargas Rohrmoser, the Commission is seeking three things: a) that execution
of the judgment of conviction delivered by the San José First Circuit Criminal Trial
Court on November 12, 1999, be suspended; b) that Mauricio Herrera Ulloa’s name
not be listed in the Judiciary’s Record of Convicted Felons, and c) that the State
refrain from taking any measure that would be prejudicial to the right to freedom of
expression that Mauricio Herrera Ulloa and the newspaper La Nación enjoy.
6.
That freedom of expression, recognized in Article 13 of the Convention, is a
cornerstone upon which the very existence of a democratic society rests. It is
indispensable for the formation of public opinion. It is also a condition sine qua non
for the development of political parties, trade unions, scientific and cultural societies
and, in general, those who wish to influence the public. It represents, in short, the
means that enable the community, when exercising its options, to be sufficiently
informed. Consequently, it can be said that a society that is not well informed is not
a society that is truly free. 1
7.
That an order must be given to suspend La Nación’s publication of the
operative paragraphs of the judgment of conviction that the San José First Circuit
Criminal Trial Court delivered on November 12, 1999 and its creation of a “link” at
the La Nación Digital website between the contested newspaper articles and the
operative paragraphs of that judgment, since such a publication and such a link
would cause irreparable harm to Mauricio Herrera Ulloa. No irreparable harm would
be done, however, if the other operative paragraphs of that judgment were enforced.
Execution of those paragraphs should be suspended until the case is finally settled by
the organs of the inter-American system for the protection of human rights;
8.
That the Court will not rule on the matter of the removal of the link at La
Nación Digital that connects the surname Przedborski to the contested articles delinkage ordered in the judgment of the San José First Circuit Criminal Trial Court
on November 12, 1999- since the question of delinkage goes to the merits of the
petition now before the Inter-American Commission, and is not material to
provisional measures;
9.
That the entry of Herrera Ulloa’s name in the Judiciary’s Record of Convicted
Felons, created by Law No. 6723 of March 10, 1982, warrants special attention. The
1
Cfr. Compulsory membership in an association prescribed by law for the practice of journalism
(Arts. 13 and 29 American Convention on Human Rights). Advisory Opinion OC-5/85 of November 13,
1985. Series A No.5, paragraphs 70 and 71.