66 ii) she worked as a waitress and the income she contributed paid for her children’s studies and to support the family; she helped her mother financially on a fortnightly or weekly basis;140 and iii) she was married. Her children are Alejandro Idelfonso, Yovanny Manuel, Ydel Ramón, all of them Ramírez, Elsa Julia Batista Ramírez, and Ybelice Altagracia Ramírez. Her sister is Marisol Vitalina Ramírez Caminero.141 66.48. José Ramón Montenegro Cordero i) he was born on May 27, 1960 and died on March 3, 1989 at the age of twenty-eight due to “intra-cranial hemorrhage, a firearm wound to the skull.” The next of kin were never informed of the whereabouts of the corpse;142 ii) he worked as a mason and a painter; he supported his mother and his younger siblings with his contributions;143 and iii) he was single. His parents are Nicasia Cordero and José Gregorio Montenegro. His siblings are Marisol, José Ramón, and Francisco Rafael, all of them Montenegro Cordero.144 66.49. Jesús Alberto Cartaya i) he was born on April 28, 1961 and died on March 1, 1989 at the age of twenty-seven due to an “acute pulmonary edema”;145 and 140 Cf. testimony of Ybelice Altagracia Ramírez rendered on March 27, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District. 141 Cf. excerpt from birth certificate of Alejandro Idelfonso Ramírez dated April 12, 2000 issued by the Administrative Office on Marital Status of the Central Electoral Board of the Dominican Republic; excerpt from birth certificate of Yovanny Manuel Ramírez dated April 12, 2000 issued by the Administrative Office on Marital Status of the Central Electoral Board of the Dominican Republic; excerpt from birth certificate of Ybelice Altagracia Ramírez dated April 25, 2000 issued by the Administrative Office on Marital Status of the Central Electoral Board of the Dominican Republic; excerpt from birth certificate of Ydel Ramón Ramírez dated April 12, 2000 issued by the Administrative Office on Marital Status of the Central Electoral Board of the Dominican Republic; and excerpt from birth certificate of Elsa Julia Batista Ramírez dated July 20, 2000 issued by the Administrative Office on Marital Status of the Central Electoral Board of the Dominican Republic. 142 Cf. copy of the birth certificate of José Ramón Montenegro Cordero issued on September 16, 1999 by the Civil Head Office of San Juan, Prefecture of Libertador Municipality in the Federal District; autopsy record No. 51.446 prepared by the Forensic Medicine Division of the Technical Corps of the Judiciary Police; and testimony of Marisol Montenegro Cordero rendered on March 22, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District. 143 Cf. testimony of Marisol Montenegro Cordero rendered on March 22, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District. 144 Cf. copy of the birth certificate of José Ramón Montenegro Cordero issued on September 16, 1999 by the Civil Head Office of San Juan, Prefecture of Libertador Municipality in the Federal District; copy of the birth certificate of Marisol Montenegro Cordero issued on January 23, 1997 by the Civil Head Office of San Juan, Prefecture of Libertador Municipality in the Federal District; and testimony of Marisol Montenegro Cordero rendered on March 22, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District.