69 Victims of violations of the right to fair trial and to judicial protection 66.54. Abelardo Antonio Pérez i) he was born on March 22, 1948 and disappeared when he was forty years old, on March 22, 1948. At the date of the instant judgment, his whereabouts had not yet been established;156 ii) he was a master “cabillas” builder and he contributed income to cover household expenses;157 and iii) His mother is Oscarina Pérez.158 66.55. Andrés Eloy Suárez Sánchez i) he was born on September 22, 1956 and he disappeared at the age of 32 on February 27, 1989;159 and ii) he was single. His parents are María Antonia Sánchez and Graciliano Suárez. His siblings are Juan Carlos and María Lourdes, both of them Suárez Sánchez.160 66.56. Jesús Rafael Villalobos iii) he has been missing since February 28, 1989;161 and iv) his brother is Franco José Márquez Villalobos. 155 Cf. March 5, 1993 certification of the birth certificate of Petra Zulay Mena Marrero issued by the Main Records Office of the State of Miranda; birth certificate of Laura Josefina Marrero issued on September 8, 1989 by the Civil Authority of Sucre, Libertador Department of the Federal District; birth certificate of Maribel Sugey Marrero issued on September 8, 1989 by the Civil Authority of Sucre, Libertador Department of the Federal District; and testimony of Petra Bello rendered on March 27, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District. 156 Cf. El Caracazo Case, supra note 28, para. 1; and testimony of Fernán Enrique Pérez rendered on March 27, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District. 157 Cf. testimony of Fernán Enrique Pérez rendered on March 27, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District. 158 Cf. testimony of Fernán Enrique Pérez rendered on March 27, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District. 159 Cf. copy of the birth certificate of Andrés Eloy Suárez Sánchez by the Prefect of San Juan Bautista Municipality in the Federal District; and testimony of Juan Carlos Suárez Sánchez rendered on March 26, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District. 160 Cf. copy of the birth certificate of María Lourdes Suárez Sánchez issued on December 7, 1976 by the Prefect of San Sebastián Municipality in the San Cristóbal District; copy of the birth certificate of Juan Carlos Suárez Sánchez issued on April 21, 1978 by the Prefect of San Juan Bautista Municipality in the Federal District; and testimony of Juan Carlos Suárez Sánchez rendered on March 26, 2002 at the 29th Notary Public of Libertador Municipality of the Federal District. 161 Cf. El Caracazo Case, supra note 28, para. 1.