7
Therefore, whenever it goes beyond its natural limits in order to penetrate, in the
name of totalitarian claims, into the sanctuary of the conscience, it endeavours to violate
this latter by monstrous means of psychological poisoning, of organized lies and of
terror.(...)" 25.
20.
More than four decades later, at the end of the eighties, Giuseppe Sperduti did
not hesitate to affirm, in an emphatic criticism to legal positivism, that
- "(...) la doctrine positiviste n'a pas été en mesure d'élaborer une conception du
droit international aboutissant à l'existence d'un véritable ordre juridique (...). Il faut voir
dans la conscience commune des peuples, ou conscience universelle, la source des normes
suprêmes du droit international" 26.
21.
References of the kind, nowadays surely susceptible of a larger and deeper
conceptual development, are not limited to the doctrinal level; they also appear in
international treaties. The Convention against Genocide of 1948, e.g., refers, in its
preamble, to the "spirit" of the United Nations. Half a century later, the preamble of the
Statute of Rome of 1998 of the International Criminal Court bears witness of the fact
that, throughout the XXth century,
- "(...) millions of children, women and men have been victims of unimaginable
atrocities that deeply shock the conscience of humanity" (second considerandum).
And, at regional level, the preamble of the Inter-American Convention on Forced
Disappearance of Persons of 1994, to quote another example, refers to the "conscience
of the hemisphere" (third considerandum).
22.
A clause of major importance deserves to be singled out: the so-called Martens
clause, which has more than a century of historical trajectory. Originally presented by
the Delegate of Russia, Friedrich von Martens, to the I Peace Conference of The Hague
(1899), it was inserted into the preambles of the II Hague Convention of 1899 (par. 9)
and the IV Hague Convention of 1907 (par. 8), both pertaining to the laws and
customs of land warfare. Its purpose - according to the wise premonition of the Russian
jurist and diplomat - was to extend juridically the protection to civilians and to
combatants in all situations, even though not contemplated by the conventional norms;
with that aim, the Martens clause invoked "the principles of the law of nations (droit
des gens)" derived from "the usages established", as well as "the laws of humanity"
and "the dictates (exigences) of public conscience".
23.
Subsequently, the Martens clause was to appear again in the provision,
concerning denunciation, common to the four Geneva Conventions of International
Humanitarian Law of 1949 (Article 63/62/142/158), as well as in the Additional
Protocol I (of 1977) to those Conventions (Article 1(2)), - to quote some of the main
Conventions on International Humanitarian Law. The Martens clause is thus endowed,
for more than a century, of continuing validity, since, however advanced the
codification of the humanitarian norms might be, such codification can hardly be
considered as truly complete.
25
.
26
Ibid., pp. 81-82.
.
G. Sperduti, "La souveraineté, le droit international et la sauvegarde des droits de la personne", in
International Law at a Time of Perplexity - Essays in Honour of Shabtai Rosenne (ed. Y. Dinstein), Dordrecht,
Nijhoff, 1989, p. 884, and cf. p. 880.