45
young victims in this case and to place in this center a plaque with the names of
Henry Giovanni Contreras, Federico Clemente Figueroa Túnchez, Julio Roberto Caal
Sandoval, Jovito Josué Juárez Cifuentes and Anstraun Aman Villagrán Morales. This
will contribute to raising awareness in order to avoid the repetition of harmful acts
such as those that occurred in the instant case and will keep the memory of the
victims alive91.
X
COSTS AND EXPENSES
Arguments of the representatives of the victims’ next of kin
104.
The representatives of the victims’ next of kin indicated that:
a)
the next of kin incurred various expenses before the authorities in the
domestic judicial proceedings to investigate the deaths of the victims: travel
to police stations and judicial offices, time invested in statements,
photocopies, obtaining birth and death certificates, etc. Although there is no
precise documentation with regard to these expenses, they should be
reimbursed by the State and the Court can establish them based on the
principle of equity;
b)
the actions taken by the victims, their successors or their
representatives to obtain the jurisdictional decision recognizing the violation
committed and establishing the legal consequences resulted in expenses
incurred before both the domestic and the international instances;
c)
in this case, several proceedings were filed at the internal level and,
although they were ineffective, they generated a series of expenses and
costs. The petitioners are requesting that the Court grant compensation for
the expenses incurred by Casa Alianza in supporting and representing the
victims’ next of kin. Although there is no evidence to show the precise
amount of such expenses, the sum of US$ 3,500.00 (three thousand five
hundred United States dollars) is considered to be a fair estimate;
d)
Casa Alianza and CEJIL have defended the victims’ next of kin in the
proceeding before the inter-American system and request reimbursement of
their expenses;
e)
Casa Alianza has incurred expenses related to air tickets and airport
taxes, accommodation and subsistence, internal transport, telephone calls
and faxes, mailing parcels by air, totaling US$ 24,151.91 (twenty-four
thousand one hundred and fifty-one United States dollars and ninety-one
cents); and
f)
CEJIL has incurred expenses related to two hearings before the
Commission and three hearings before the Court, telephone and fax bills,
courier expenses and office supplies (copies, stationery, etc.) totaling US$
11,710.00 (eleven thousand seven hundred and ten United States dollars).
The Commission’s arguments
91
cf. Benavides Ceballos case. Judgment of June 19, 1998. Series C No. 38, paras. 48.5 and 55;
and Aloeboetoe et al. case. Reparations, supra note 15, para. 96.
Seleccionar párrafo de destino3
Conectar a un párrafo
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Añadir a la tabla de contenidos