59
his or her personal integrity has been violated, for such features may change the
insight of his or her individual reality and, therefore, increase the suffering and the
sense of humiliation when the person is subjected to certain types of treatment.
2. The right to the respect for the dignity and autonomy of the persons with mental illness and to
effective health care
128. The States have the duty to guarantee the provision of effective health care
services to all persons with mental illness. 114 This duty entails the obligation of the
State to ensure the access to basic health care to all persons, the promotion of
mental health, the provision of such services in the least restrictive possible way,
and the prevention of mental illness.115
129. Due to their psychological and emotional condition, persons with mental
illness are particularly vulnerable to any health treatment, and such vulnerability is
greater when they are admitted to mental health institutions. This increased
vulnerability is due to the imbalance of power between patients and the medical staff
responsible for their treatment, as well as to the high degree of intimacy which is
typical of the treatment of psychiatric illnesses.116
130. The Court considers that any health treatment administered to persons with
mental illness should aim at achieving the patient´s welfare and the respect for his
or her dignity as a human person, which is translated into the duty to adopt the
respect for the intimacy and autonomy of persons as guiding principles for
administering psychiatric treatment. The Court concedes that the foregoing principle
is not absolute, since the patients´needs themselves may sometimes require the
adoption of measures without their consent. Notwithstanding, mental illnesses
should not be understood as a disability for determination and the assumption that
persons with mental illness are capable of expressing their will, which should be
respected by both the medical staff and the authorities, should prevail. When the
patients´inability to give their consent has been proven, their next of kin, legal
representatives or pertinent authorities will give the consent required as regards to
the treatment to be administered thereto.117
114
Cf. Principles for the Protection of People with Mental Health Illness and the Improvement of
Health Care, supra note 32, principle 1; Division of Mental Health and Prevention of Substance Abuse of
the World Health Organization. Ten Basic Principles of Mental Health Care Law, supra note 37, principle 2;
Standard Rules on the Equalization of Opportunities for Persons with Disabilities. UN General Assembly
Resolution No. 48/96, Document A/48/49 (1993), art. 2; Declaration on the Rights of Mentally Retarded
Persons. UN General Assembly Resolution, Document A/8429 (1971), art. 2; and World Program of Action
Concerning Disabled People. UN General Assembly Resolution No. 37/52, Document A/37/51 (1982),
paras. 95 to 107.
115
Cf. Inter-American Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Persons
with Disabilities, supra note. 35, Article III(2); and World Health Organization. Division of Mental Health
and Prevention of Substance Abuse. Ten Basic Principles of Mental Health Care Law, supra note 37,
principles 1, 2, and 4.
116
Cf. Standard Rules on the Equalization of Opportunities for Persons with Disabilities, supra note
114, art. 9(4); Committee on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights, General Comment No. 5 “Persons
with Disabilities”, supra note 35, para. 9; and Standards of the European Committee for the Prevention of
Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, CPT/Inf/E (2002) 1 – Rev. 2004, para. 51.
In this regard, cf. European Court of Human Rights, Keenan v. United Kingdom, Application No. 27229/95,
judgment of April 3, 2001, p. 111, and European Court of Human Rights, Herczegfalvy v. Austria,
Application No. 10533/83, judgment of September 24, 1992, p. 82.
117
Cf. Principles for the Protection of People with Mental Illness and the Improvement of Health
Care, supra note 32, principles 9(4) and 11; Division of Mental Health and Prevention of Substance Abuse