8 initiative of the victim or his family or upon their offer of proof, without an effective search for the truth by the government”22. 16. That, it is necessary for the State to report on the adoption of all the measures necessary to comply with the duty to “conduct the corresponding investigations and apply the pertinent punishments to those responsible for failing to abide by the judicial decisions delivered by the Peruvian courts during the applications for protective measures filed by the victims” (operative paragraph six of the Judgment of February 28, 2003). Especially, it is necessary for the State to inform in which way the decisions adopted up to the present by the state authorities (supra Considering clauses 12 and 13) have responded to the decision made by this Tribunal to that effect. Furthermore, the Court deems it is vital for the State to inform on the steps taken to conduct a thorough investigation different to the one conducted by the criminal courts. * * * 17. That, regarding the State’s obligation to pay Mr. Carlos Benvenuto Torres, Javier Mujica Ruiz Huidrobo, Guillermo Alvarez Hernández, Reymert Bartra Vásquez and the widow of Mr. Maximiliano Gamarra Ferrerya, the amount fixed for nonpecuniary damage and the amount established as costs and expenses in their favor (supra Having Seen clauses 3.b and 3.c, respectively), the State indicated that it has complied with the aspects ordered in operative paragraphs seven and eight of the Judgment. In that respect, it indicated that on December 28, 2005, it paid to each one of the victims the amount of US$ 6,300 (six thousand three hundred dollars of the United State of America) equivalent to $ 21.552,30 new soles (twenty-one thousand five hundred and fifty-two and 30/100 new soles) for those items23. In 22 Case of Velásquez Rodríguez V. Honduras. Merits. Judgment of July 29, 1988. Series C No. 4, para. 177 and Case of Godínez Cruz V. Honduras. Merits. Judgment of January 20, 1989. Series C Nº. 5, para. 188; Case of Caballero Delgado and Santana V. Colombia, Merits. Judgment of December 8, 1995. Series C Nº 22, para. . 58; Case of Cantoral Huamaní and García Santa Cruz V. Perú. Preliminary Objection, Merits, Reparations and Costs. Judgment of July 10, 2007. Series C Nº. 167, para. 131 and Case of Valle Jaramillo et al. V. Colombia. Merits, Reparations and Costs. Judgment of November 27, 2008. Series C Nº 192, para. 100. 23 Cf. payment receipt in the name of Carlos Alberto Torres Benvenuto, issued by the Ministry of Justice – Administration General Office, on December 23, 2005 for the amount of 21.552,30 (twenty-one thousand five hundred and fifty two with 30/100 new soles) (record on monitoring compliance, volume III, page 662); cash receipt of December 28, 2005 signed by Mr. Carlos Benvenuto (record on monitoring compliance, Volume III, page 663); payment receipt in the name of Javier Mujica Ruíz Huidrobo, issued by the Ministry of Justice- Administration General Office, on December 23, 2005 for the amount of 21.552,30 (twenty-one thousand five hundred and fifty-two with 30/100 new soles) (record on monitoring compliance, volume III; page 664); cash receipt of December 28, 2005 signed by Patricia Mujica Petit (record on monitoring compliance, volume III, page 665); payment receipt in the name of Guillermo Álvarez Hernández, issued by the Ministry of Justice- Administration General Office on December 23, 2005 for the amount of 21.552,30 (twenty one thousand five hundred and fifty-two with 30/100 new soles) (record on monitoring compliance, volume III, page 666); cash receipt of December 28, 2005 signed by Guillermo Álvarez Hernández (record on monitoring compliance, volume III, page 667); payment receipt in the name of Reymert Bartra Vásquez, issued by the Ministry of Justice- Administration General Office of December 23, 2005 for the amount of 21.552,30 (twenty one thousand five hundred and fifty-two with 30/100 new soles) (record on monitoring compliance, volume III, page 668); cash receipt of December 28, 2005 signed by Reymert Bartra Vásquez (record on monitoring compliance, volume III, page669); payment receipt in the name of Sara Elena Castro Remy widow of Gamarra, issued by the Ministry of Justice- Administration General Office of December 23, 2005 for the amount of 21.552,30 (twenty one thousand five hundred and fifty-two with 30/100 new soles) (record on monitoring compliance, volume

Seleccionar párrafo de destino3