-78prosecution (statements) that “did not resist an objective analysis that would support the charges that have been laid.” The Chamber added: “Lastly, it has been proved by expert evidence that there are several trails on the route from Pueblo Bello to San Pedro de Urabá, and this leads to the conclusion that the trucks in which the people were transported did not necessarily have to pass by San Pedro de Urabá, where there was a military base and a roadblock.” The Chamber considered “in keeping with the findings of the Office of the Delegate Disciplinary Attorney for the defense of human rights, that there is a reasonable doubt concerning the conduct of the person disciplined, which should be decided in his favor.”] Administrative proceedings a) First group of next of kin of those who have died or are disappeared 95(148) On December 18, 2001, some of the next of kin of José del Carmen Álvarez Blanco, Jesús Humberto Barbosa Vega, Santiago Manuel González López and Ángel Benito Jiménez Julio, on their own behalf and in representation of the minors, formulated a claim for direct reparation “against the Colombian Nation – Ministry of National Defense,” before the Administrative Affairs Court of Antioquia, Medellín, in which they stated that: The Colombian Nation – Ministry of National Defense – National Army is administratively responsible for the non-pecuniary damage, including that derived from alterations in family, social and affective life, caused to the persons included in the claim […] as a consequence of the violation of the rights to life, humane treatment, safety and liberty arising from the collective forced disappearance of which the following were victims: Álvarez [Blanco] José del Carmen, Barbosa Vega Jesús Humberto, González López Santiago Manuel and Jiménez Julio Ángel Benito in facts that occurred on January 14, 1990, in the jurisdiction of Pueblo Bello of the municipality of Turbo (Antioquia). […]The Colombian Nation – Ministry of National Defense – National Army is administratively responsible for the non-pecuniary damage, including that derived from alterations in family, social and affective life, caused to the persons included in the claim […] as a consequence of the violation of the rights to effective judicial protection, a fair trial, the truth, and justice arising from the collective forced disappearance of which the following were victims: Álvarez [Blanco] José del Carmen, Barbosa Vega Jesús Humberto, González López Santiago Manuel and Jiménez Julio Ángel Benito in events that took place on January 14, 1990, in the jurisdiction of Pueblo Bello, in the municipality of Turbo (Antioquia).174 95(149) On May 27, 2002, the complaint was admitted by the Administrative Affairs Court of Antioquia, Medellín.175 95(150) On November 21, 2002, some of the next of kin of José del Carmen Álvarez Blanco, Genor José Arrieta Lora, Jesús Humberto Barbosa Vega, Ricardo Manuel Bohórquez Pastrana, Jorge Fermín Calle Hernández, César Augusto Espinosa Pulgarín, Andrés Manuel Florez Altamiranda, Wilson Uberto Fuentes Miramón, Santiago Manuel González López, Miguel Ángel Gutiérrez Arrieta, Carmelo Manuel Guerra Pestana, Ángel Benito Jiménez Julio, Mario Melo Palacios, Raúl Pérez Martínez, Benito Pérez Pedroza, Andrés Manuel Peroza Jiménez, José Manuel Petro 174 Cf. complaint filed on December 18, 2001, by the next of kin of José del Carmen Álvarez Ruiz, Jesús Humberto Barbosa Vega, Santiago Manuel González López and Ángel Benito Jiménez Julio, before the Administrative Affairs Court of Antioquía, Medellín (file of useful evidence submitted by the representatives, folios 7305 to 7342). 175 Cf. report presented by the legal representative in the administrative proceedings (file of useful evidence submitted by the representatives, folio 7469). Uncontested.