TABLE OF CONTENTS I INTRODUCTION OF THE CASE AND PURPOSE OF THE DISPUTE..................................... 3 II PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COURT ............................................................................. 4 III JURISDICTION ........................................................................................................... 5 IV PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ........................................................................................ 5 A) Objection regarding the failure to exhaust domestic remedies ..........................................5 B) Alleged violation of the right to defense ......................................................................................7 V EVIDENCE ..................................................................................................................... 9 VI FACTS ....................................................................................................................... 10 A) Beginning of actions and detention of Mr. Carranza ............................................................. 10 B) Continuation of the criminal trial after the detention ........................................................... 11 C) The sentence and serving the sentence ...................................................................................... 12 VII MERITS ................................................................................................................... 13 PERSONAL LIBERTY AND JUDICIAL GUARANTEES ......................................................... 13 A) Allegations of the Commission and the parties ...................................................................... 13 B) Considerations of the Court ............................................................................................................. 14 B.1 Detention and preventive detention orders for Mr. Carranza........................................ 17 B.1.1 Initial detention ............................................................................................... 17 B.1.2 Preventive detention ........................................................................................ 18 B.2 Review of preventive detention ............................................................................... 20 B.3 Reasonableness of the length of the preventive deprivation of liberty ........................... 20 B.4 Presumption of innocence ....................................................................................... 21 B.5 Length of the criminal trial ...................................................................................... 21 B.6 Conclusion ............................................................................................................ 22 VIII REPARATIONS ....................................................................................................... 23 A) Injured party ......................................................................................................................................... 23 B) Measures of satisfaction ................................................................................................................... 23 C) Request for guarantees of non-repetition................................................................................. 24 D) Compensation ....................................................................................................................................... 24 E) Costs and expenses ............................................................................................................................ 25 F) Method of compliance with the payments ordered ............................................................... 25 IX OPERATIVE PARAGRAPHS ......................................................................................... 26 2