-3X. RIGHTS TO JUDICIAL PROTECTION AND JUDICIAL GUARANTEES, IN RELATION TO THE
OBLIGATION TO RESPECT AND ENSURE RIGHTS .......................................................................... 61
A. Arguments of the parties and of the Commission ............................................................................. 62
B. Considerations of the Court .......................................................................................................... 63
B.1) The alleged violation of the right to judicial protection ....................................................................... 63
B.2) Reasonable time of the extradition process ....................................................................................... 67
B.2.a) Complexity of the matter ................................................................................................. 68
B.2.b) Procedural activity of the interested party........................................................................... 68
B.2.c) Conduct of the State authorities ........................................................................................ 70
B.2.d) Effects on the legal situation of the person involved in the proceedings ................................... 72
B.2.e) Conclusion concerning a reasonable time ............................................................................ 72
B.3) Other guarantees of due process (right to be heard and right to a defense) ....................................... 72
B.3.a) Arguments of the parties and of the Commission ................................................................. 72
B.3.b) Considerations of the Court .............................................................................................. 73
XI. RIGHTS TO PERSONAL LIBERTY AND PERSONAL INTEGRITY, IN RELATION TO THE
OBLIGATION TO RESPECT AND ENSURE RIGHTS .......................................................................... 75
A. Arbitrary nature of the provisional arrest ........................................................................................ 79
A.1) Arguments of the parties and of the Commission .............................................................................. 79
A.2) Considerations of the Court ............................................................................................................. 80
B. The alleged unlawful and arbitrary nature of the detention after the decision of the Constitutional Court .. 83
B.1) Arguments of the parties and of the Commission .............................................................................. 83
B.2) Considerations of the Court ............................................................................................................. 83
C. The duration of the provisional arrest ............................................................................................ 84
C.1) Arguments of the parties and of the Commission .............................................................................. 84
C.2) Considerations of the Court ............................................................................................................. 85
D. Right to appeal before a competent court ....................................................................................... 87
D.1) Arguments of the parties and of the Commission .............................................................................. 87
D.2) Considerations of the Court ............................................................................................................. 88
D.2.a) Habeas corpus of February 9, 2010 ................................................................................... 89
D.2.b) Release request of October 5, 2011 ................................................................................... 89
D.2.c) Release request of October 18, 2011, and habeas corpus of November 16, 2011 ...................... 89
D.2.d) Failure to comply with a reasonable time when deciding these remedies ................................. 91
E. Alleged violation of the right to personal integrity of Wong Ho Wing ................................................... 92
XII. REPARATIONS ...................................................................................................................... 92
A. Injured party ............................................................................................................................. 93
B. Measures of integral reparation: restitution and satisfaction .............................................................. 93
B.1) Restitution ...................................................................................................................................... 93
B.1.a) Extradition process ......................................................................................................... 93
B.1.b) Review of the provisional arrest ........................................................................................ 94
B.2) Satisfaction .................................................................................................................................... 95
B.2.a) Publication and dissemination of the Judgment .................................................................... 95
B.3) Other measures requested............................................................................................................... 95
C. Compensation ............................................................................................................................ 95
D. Costs and expenses .................................................................................................................... 97
E. Method of complying with the payments ordered ............................................................................. 98
XIII. OPERATIVE PARAGRAPHS ................................................................................................... 99