remained sitting down. 87 He stated that he went to see “another patient (…) who was threatening to leave the
hospital and was restless.” 88 The State indicated that this occurred close to 3:30 pm. 89
52.
Nurse Borja stated that he took between fifteen to twenty minutes to return to the television
room and no longer found Mr. Guachalá there. 90 He said that he immediately searched for him in the different
halls and rooms of the hospital, but could not find him. 91 He stated that at the time of the events the on-call
doctor was not in the hospital. 92
F.
About the events as of January 18, 2004
53.
Ms. Chimbó stated that on Sunday January 18, 2004, she went to the hospital to see her son
and she spoke to the nurse who had injected her son at the time of his admission, who told her that “he had
escaped from the hospital on Saturday February 17.” 93 She said that the nurse asked whether her son had
arrived home, to which she responded that she had not seen her son since she left him at the hospital. 94 She
stated that the nurse said “that was (her) problem, (…) that they had looked for him through the entire sector
but had not found him.” 95
54.
Ms. Chimbó stated that the nurse did not want to allow her in the room that had been assigned
to her son, but that a female nurse opened the door of said room and thus she was able to enter. 96 She added
that “there was already another patient” on the bed that was assigned to Luis, that she did not find doctor
Quimbiulco and that she spoke to a shift nurse, who recommended that she look for her son “in the house of
other relatives”, so she left the hospital crying. 97
55.
Doctor Quimbiulco stated that on Monday January 19, 2004, upon arriving to the hospital, she
was informed that Mr. Guachalá “had abandoned the institution during the weekend” 98, so she ordered the
social worker, Jenny Beltran, “to carry out the respective procedures to locate the patient.” 99
56.
That same day, Ms. Chimbó came to the hospital and met with the director of the institution.
The director informed Ms. Chimbó the following:
(…) the patients become restless when the next of kin do not visit them, and regrettably the
hospital does not have high walls so it is very easy for them to leave; the personnel cares for
them but they are not enough to follow the patients that want to escape, but even so, the
personnel is usually monitoring them. 100
57.
According to the hospital’s report, that day calls were made to the San Juan de Dios Shelter, to
the San Lázaro Hospital, and the morgue, where they were informed that no person with the characteristics of
Mr. Guachalá was found. 101 Likewise, the social worker, Jenny Beltran, communicated with the National Police
to notify them of the disappearance of Mr. Guachalá. 102 According to the hospital’s report, that same day
Sergeant Max Alua came “to obtain the routine information.” 103 For her part, Ms. Chimbó said that she and her
Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
89 Communication of the State of May 20, 2016.
90 Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
91 Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
92 Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
93 Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
94 Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
95 Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
96 Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
97 Annex 6. Affidavit of Zoila Chimbó, 27 September 2005. Annex 3 to the initial petition.
98 Annex 1. Medical Report of the Julio Endara Psychiatric Hospital. Annex to the initial petition.
99 Annex 1. Medical Report of the Julio Endara Psychiatric Hospital. Annex to the initial petition.
100 Annex 3. Report of the Julio Endara Psychiatric Hospital, Social Work. Annex to the initial petition.
101 Annex 3. Report of the Julio Endara Psychiatric Hospital, Social Work. Annex to the initial petition.
102 Annex 11. Call management system of the National Police of Ecuador. Annex 8 to the initial petition.
103 Annex 3. Report of the Julio Endara Psychiatric Hospital, Social Work. Annex to the initial petition.
87
88
9