Table of Contents I INTRODUCTION OF THE CASE AND CAUSE OF ACTION ........................................... 5 II PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COURT .................................................................................. 6 III JURISDICTION ........................................................................................................................... 10 IV PARTIAL RECOGNITION OF INTERNATIONAL RESPONSIBILITY ................. 10 V PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS .................................................................................................. 13 A. First preliminary objection: “Objection on the legality of Admissibility Report 13/04 concerning Petition 136/03 for the failure to exhaust domestic remedies”................................................................................................. 13 B. Second preliminary objection: “Objection for failure to exhaust domestic remedies” .................................................................................................................... 17 C. Third preliminary objection: “Objection calling for a review of the legality of Report on the Merits 66/11 regarding the identification of the alleged victims and human rights not included in Admissibility Report 13/04;” 20 D. Fourth preliminary objection: “Objection on the grounds that the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights violated the Peruvian State’s right of defense;” ........................................................................................................ 26 E. Fifth preliminary objection: “Objection for omission of relevant material” ........................................................................................................................................... 28 VI PRELIMINARY CONSIDERATIONS ................................................................................... 29 A. Alleged inadmissibility of facts ....................................................................... 29 B. victim Decision on the status of Lucinda Rojas Landa as an alleged 31 VII EVIDENCE ..................................................................................................................................... 33 A. Documentary, testimonial and expert evidence .................................................. 33 B. Admission of evidence ........................................................................................................ 33 B.1 Admission of documentary evidence .................................................................. 33 B.2 Admission of statements and expert opinions ................................................. 36 B.3 Admission of videos .................................................................................................... 37 C. Assessment of the Evidence ............................................................................. 39 D. Evidentiary value and assessment of the “procedure to reconstruct the facts” ............................................................................................................... 39 VIII FACTS ........................................................................................................................................... 41 A. Context .......................................................................................................................... 41