g) An Assistant Commissioner of the Police of the province of Buenos Aires who had taken part in the investigation from the start, stated that, following the execution of Mr. Gutiérrez, the federal police agent indicted for his murder telephoned him to ask for information on the investigation, in order “to collaborate” with it. 225 114. Subsequently, in July and September 2001, the judge of the proceeding asked the Prosecutor General to appoint “urgently” judicial investigators from the Office of the Prosecutor General of the Supreme Court of Buenos Aires, because, “from the testimony [… received,] it appeared that high-ranking members of the Federal Police and the Police of the province of Buenos Aires could be involved in the incident.” 226 These requests were refused on September 20, 2001, owing to the lack of “availability” of judicial investigators. 227 In this regard, this Court observes that article 436 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the province of Buenos Aires applicable to this case imposed on the judges and police officials the obligation “to investigate all actionable offenses that they become aware of in any way,” and that the latter are the judge’s “assistants.” 228 In this regard, expert witness Gabriel Pérez Barberá advised the Court that: If a wrongful act is committed by the member of an institution with a corporate culture and practices, it is highly probable that, if this same institution conducts the investigation to establish who was responsible for the wrongful act, this investigation will tend to conceal it […]. 115. In addition, the Court takes note that, on January 20, 2003, one of the guards of the train in which Mr. Gutiérrez died stated during the proceeding that, following the detention of the federal police agent indicted, he had been summoned by the Argentine Federal Police to come to “their precinct, in Plaza Constitución,” where they asked him about the murder and “told him that he should give them a hand to help their colleague […] who was in prison for murdering Assistant Commissioner Gutiérrez, and that they wanted to get him out of there.” 229 116. That same month Commissioner Jorge Luis Piazza, 230 who had been in charge of the investigation of the execution of Mr. Gutiérrez from the start and whose statement had been requested by the injured parties in May 2001, was murdered. 231 Criminal proceedings were opened with regard to the murder of Commissioner Piazza; however, on June 19, 2008, the 225 Cf. Statement of October 6, 2000 before Transitional Court No. 2 of La Plata (file of annexes to the submission brief, folios 220 to 221). 226 Cf. Note of September 17, 2001, from the judge of the proceeding to the Prosecutor General of the La Plata Judicial Department (file of annexes to the submission brief, folio 276), and Note of July 12, 2001, from the judge of the proceeding to the Prosecutor General of the La Plata Judicial Department (file of annexes to the pleadings and motions brief, folio 1821). 227 Cf. Note of September 20, 2001, from the Prosecutor General of the La Plata Judicial Department to Transitional Court No. 2 of La Plata (file of annexes to the pleadings and motions brief, folio 1824). 228 Article 436 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the province of Buenos Aires establishes: “The police officials and the judge shall proceed immediately to investigate all actionable offenses that they become aware of in any way. The former, within twenty-four (24) hours, shall inform the latter, as well as the prosecutor, and the official defender on duty, and shall continue the investigation until the judge arrives; they will then act as the latter’s assistants. In addition, the investigator shall advise the judge that he has complied with the provisions of article 210 of this Code." Available at: http://www.gob.gba.gov.ar/dijl/DIJL_buscaid.php?var=1334. 229 Cf. Testimony of January 20, 2003, Fs. 2092/2094, Proceeding 10,888 (file of annexes to the pleadings and motions brief, folios 1850 and 1851). 230 Cf. Obituary notice of Jorge Luis Piazza, Fs. 2187, Proceeding 10,888, of February 26, 2003 (file of annexes to the pleadings and motions brief, folio 1859), and Decision of June 19, 2008, Case No. 19,325, of the Second Court of the Criminal Appeals and Guarantees Chamber of the province of Buenos Aires (file of annexes to the pleadings and motions brief, folios 2331 and 2344). 231 Cf. Brief of May 2, 2001, addressed by the injured parties to the judge of the proceeding (file of annexes to the pleadings and motions brief, folio 1837). 45

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents