State; expenses related to the inability to study; loss of possessions, and also harm to the
physical, mental and emotional health of the family concerned. 280
183. The Court takes note that, in this case, the next of kin of Jorge Omar Gutiérrez were
declared victims of the violation of the rights to judicial guarantees and protection, as well
as to personal integrity owing to his death and the impunity in which the case remains.
Thus, it considers that what the representatives indicate as “damage to the family wealth” is
not a direct consequence of these violations, and that, in this case, it is subsumed within
the amounts for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage. Therefore, the Court will not order
an additional amount for this concept. In the section on costs and expenses, the Court will
assess those financial disbursements related to the expenses entailed by keeping open the
proceedings and the demand for justice (supra para. 176 and infra para. 193).
D.2. Non-pecuniary damage
184. In its case law, the Court has developed the concept of non-pecuniary damage and
has established that this “may include both the suffering and afflictions caused by the
violation, and also the impairment of values of great significance for the individual, as well
as any change, of a non-pecuniary nature, in the living conditions of the victims.” 281
185. The representatives stated that “the non-pecuniary damage suffered by the next of
kin of Jorge Omar Gutiérrez, resulted from: (a) the violent death of a loved one at the
hands of State agents; (b) the ineffectiveness of the system of justice to investigate the
facts; (c) the distortion and concealment of the facts by public officials, some of them
colleagues of the victim; (d) the versions aimed at harming the reputation of Jorge Omar
Gutiérrez and creating impunity; (e) the failure of the criminal actions filed […] (despite
persistent requests and direct investigations by the family members); (f) the intimidation,
threats, attacks, and other acts of violence suffered by key witnesses in the judicial
proceedings; (g) the accusations against them because they organized activities to avoid
collective oblivion in relation to the crime; (h) the State’s lack of protection in the face of
possible attacks by the perpetrators and masterminds interested in ensuring impunity,
despite the fears expressed by the family[, and] (i) the State’s absence of political will and
the disregard of the demands for justice by public officials and a deliberate lack of respect
during the friendly settlement procedure.” In addition, the representatives argued as part of
the non-pecuniary damage “the change in the living conditions of each member of the
family.” Consequently, the representatives asked the Court to establish, in equity, a
compensatory amount for the wife of Jorge Omar Gutiérrez, his three children, his sister
Nilda Gutiérrez, and his brother Francisco Gutiérrez. Meanwhile, in the Agreement, the
parties asked the Court to rule on the scope of the reparations for the victims, which should
include compensation for non-pecuniary damage, based on the principle of equity (supra
para. 17). The Commission did not refer to this point.
186. As the Court has indicated on other occasions, 282 in cases such as this one, the nonpecuniary damage inflicted on the victim is evident. In this regard, the Court decides to
order the State to pay compensation of US$75,000.00 (seventy-five thousand United States
dollars) for the non-pecuniary damage suffered by Jorge Omar Gutiérrez. This sum must be
delivered integrally and in equal parts to the victim’s wife and children, respectively, Nilda
del Valle Maldonado de Gutiérrez, Jorge Gabriel, Omar David and Marilin Verónica Gutiérrez.
280
Cf. Case of Gutiérrez Soler, supra, para. 78, and Case of Baldeón García, supra, para. 186.
281
Case of the “Street Children” (Villagrán Morales et al.), supra, para. 84, and Case of Luna López, supra,
para. 251.
282
Cf. Case of Zambrano Vélez et al., supra, para. 142, and Case of Kawas Fernández, supra, para. 194.
61
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents