72
Ortega was taking part in the initial organization of the women of her community,
as revealed by specific declarations and expert opinions; iii) the rape had an
intimidating effect, “obviously, [Mrs.] Fernández Ortega’s rape impeded her
participation in the organization, as well as that of other women, and this was due
to the impunity in the case and to the increase in harassment and threats against
the victim, her family, and those who have accompanied her process of seeking
justice,” and iv) the rape of Mrs. Fernández Ortega forms part of the context of
violence suffered by the grass-roots indigenous organizations of Guerrero, such as
OPIM.
217. In summary, the State alleged that the Court is unable to examine the
violation of the right to freedom of association in this case, because “the petitioners
may not invoke facts that are distinct from those contained in the Commission’s
application” and that brief “never mentions a policy of harassment against OPIM or
other organizations for the defense of human rights in Guerrero. The situation of
OPIM […] is not part of the litis”; in addition, “neither the alleged actions against
OPIM, nor the alleged violation of Article 16(1) were indicated at any time by the
petitioners throughout the processing of the case before the Commission,” so that
“[a]t this stage of the proceedings, to admit the claim that the State violated Article
16 of the Convention to the detriment of members of that organization would
amount to depriving the State of its right to be heard in a fair trial.” Despite the
foregoing, the State, also indicated that it had not violated Mrs. Fernández Ortega’s
right to freedom of association because it had complied with all the positive and
negative obligations deriving from it. Among other measures, the State had
adopted precautionary and provisional measures with regard to the individuals
linked directly and indirectly to the case, initiated several preliminary inquiries, and
held working meetings with the representatives. Additionally, the right to freedom
of association is extensively guaranteed by law and a petition for amparo
[protection of constitutional rights] can be filed to achieve the restitution of the
right if any possible act of an authority unduly limits it. Finally, the State referred to
other initiatives to protect and promote human rights defenders, such as the
mechanisms for dialogue with their organizations. Based on the abovementioned,
Mexico asked the Court to withhold itself from examining the alleged violation of
freedom of association or to “declare that the violation [of this] right has not been
proven.”
218. The Court observes that, in its application, the Commission did not argue the
alleged violation of the right to freedom of association; rather these allegations
were only made by the representatives. This Court has established that the alleged
victims, their next of kin, or their representatives may invoke rights other than
those included in the Commission’s application, based on the facts that the latter
has presented.234
219. In its application, the Commission described facts relating to the rape
perpetrated against Mrs. Fernández Ortega and the failure to investigate it, and
indicated that the rape took place in a context of the violation of the human rights
of indigenous people in the region of Guerrero attributed to soldiers present in the
area. However, the alleged participation of Mrs. Fernández Ortega in OPIM, her
involvement in the defense of the women of her community, and the prevention of
or decrease in the participation of women in OPIM as a result of Mrs. Fernández
Ortega’s rape do not appear in the application. Since the representatives’
arguments concerning the alleged violation of Mrs. Fernández Ortega’s right to
freedom of association are linked to these facts that do not appear in the
234
Cf. The “Five Pensioners” v. Perú, supra note 140, para. 153; Case of Ríos et al., supra note 46,
para. 42, and Case of Perozo et al., supra note 46, para. 32.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents