20.
The State argues that the inter-American system
recognizes that military criminal courts have a restricted and exceptional
jurisdiction and that the Inter-American Court itself has argued:
In a democratic Government of Laws the penal military
jurisdiction shall have a restrictive and exceptional scope
and shall lead to the protection of special juridical interests,
related to the functions assigned by law to the military
forces. Consequently, civilians must be excluded from the
military jurisdiction scope and only the military shall be
judged by commission of crime or offenses that by its own
nature attempt against legally protected interests of military
order.12
21.
The State alleges that on analyzing the record and the
decisions handed down by the military criminal courts in the proceeding
into the death of Gustavo Villamizar, one finds that the persons tried
were active-duty members of the military and that the conduct for which
they were investigated and tried correspond to those that may be heard
by the military justice system. The State alleges that the National Army
forces, in carrying out the military operation known as “Júpiter,” whose
objective was to capture members of the ELN guerrilla force who were
engaged in criminal activity in the region, had set up a checkpoint on
the road on which Gustavo Villamizar was travelling, and that when he
became aware of the military presence he attempted to evade the
checkpoint, ignored the call of “stop, National Army,” and shot at the
members of the Army, who “reacted by shooting the individual.” 13
23826/1221 of the Bureau of Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law,
Ministry of Foreign Relations of the Republic of Colombia, June 1, 2009.
12 The State makes reference to the I/A Court H.R., Durand and Ugarte v. Peru Case.
Judgment of August 16, 2000. Series C No. 68, para. 117; I/A Court H.R., Cantoral
Benavides v. Peru Case. Judgment of August 18, 2000. Series C No. 69, para. 113,
and I/A Court H.R., Las Palmeras v. Colombia Case. Judgment of December 6, 2001.
Series C No. 90, para. 51. Note DDH.GOI No. 23826/1221 of the Bureau of Human
Rights and International Humanitarian Law, Ministry of Foreign Relations of the
Republic of Colombia, June 1, 2009.
13 Note DDH.GOI No. 23826/1221 of the Bureau of Human Rights and International
Humanitarian Law, Ministry of Foreign Relations of the Republic of Colombia, June 1,
2009.
8