concern regarding the “violations of the right to life, security and to the physical and
psychological integrity of human rights advocates in Honduras, particularly environmental
activists and indigenous leaders defending rights in their communities.”31 Margaret
Sekaggya, the Special Rapporteur on the status of human rights advocates, spoke out in
this same spirit in her December 13, 2012, report on the mission to Honduras.32
23.
In 2007, in turn, the State created the “Group for the Investigation of
Environmentalists’ Deaths,” attached to the Ministry of Security, which had exclusive
responsibility for investigating cases related to deaths of the environmentalists.33 The Court
has no information regarding the period when this mechanism was operational.34
B.
Facts of the Case
B. 1. Carlos Luna López’s political actions and his defense of human rights
and of the environment
24.
Mr. Carlos Luna López was born on June 13, 1955, in city of La Ceiba in the Province
of Atlántida, Honduras.35 In 1982, he was an activist in several movements of the Liberal
Party, while at the same time supporting local farmers’ groups in their struggle for land. In
1985, he became a congressional candidate for the Province of Olancho. However, at the
end of this electoral process Mr. Luna López withdrew from political life until 1997. During
this period, Mr. Luna López continued to support the Committee for the Defense of Human
Rights in Honduras and the Visitación Padilla Women’s Peace Movement.36
25.
In 1997 Mr. Carlos Luna López took part in the general election as mayoral candidate
of the Democratic Unification Party of the Municipality of Catacamas, in Olancho Province.
As a result, he was elected to the post of Eighth Member of the City Council of Catacamas
for the 1998-2002 period.37
31
UN, Economic and Social Council. Report submitted by Hina Jilani, Special Representative of the SecretaryGeneral on Human Rights Defenders. Addendum. Compilation of advances in the area of human rights defenders,
E/CN.4/2006/95/Add.5, March 6, 2006, para. 724 (File of attachments to Merits Report, page 149).
32
UN, Human Rights Council. Report by the Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights defenders,
Margaret Sekaggya. Mission to Honduras, A/HRC/22/47Add.1, December 13, 2012, paras. 73 and 82, available at:
http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/HRBodies/HRCouncil/RegularSession/Session22/AHRC2247Add.1_Spanish.PDF, in
which the Rapporteur: “73. Observ[ed] with concern the level of violence with which they act against those using
peaceful means to claim their economic, social and cultural rights, including rights over the land. […] Many of them
live in a state of constant fear. In addition, she received information on acts of violence specifically directed at
community leaders by police officials and security guards contacted by private companies […] 82. Cases of the
defenders of human rights that protect natural resources (forests, lands, and water) have been registered and they
have been repeatedly detained, beaten and in some cases killed because of their activities. Others who report
environmental problems and inform people on their rights to the land and food have been considered as members of
the resistance, guerrillas, terrorists, political opposition or delinquents.”
33
Cf. Case of Kawas Fernández, supra, para. 70.
34
This mechanism was assessed in the Case of Kawas Fernández, supra, para. 70. In this regard, the
representatives indicated that it remained operational for a few months only and no longer exists (Merits file, page
206).
35
Cf. Erguidos Como Pinos. Memoria sobre la Construcción de la Conciencia Ambientalista (Report) by the
Committee of Families of the Detained-Disappeared in Honduras (COFADEH). Honduras, December, 2006 (File of
attachments to the Report on Merits, page 326).
36
Cf. Erguidos Como Pinos, supra (File of attachments to the Report on Merits, page 330).
37
Cf. Erguidos Como Pinos, supra (File of attachments to the Report on Merits, page 331), and Credential of
Carlos Antonio Luna López issued by the National Electoral Tribunal (File of attachments to the brief of pleadings and
motions, page 4283).
12