18 statements made thereafter[.] While the accused point[ed] out that his confession was obtained [on the] basis [of] blows, threats and torture, this is not corroborated[,] since even if there is judicial recognition of the injuries that he showed when he made his preparatory statement[,…] there is no evidence that may prove fully that said injuries were inflicted by members of the Judicial Police to force him to admit that he had committed the acts attribute[d] to him.” 58.1.16 On May 28, 1993, Mr. Alfonso Martín-del-Campo and his public defender filed an appeal against the May 28, 1993 judgment. On June 02, 1993, The Fifty-fifth Penal Judge of the Distrito Federal admitted in both aspects the appeal entered. On July 13, 1993, Mr. Martín-del-Campo’s public defender submitted his brief of grievances to the Eighth Penal Section of the Distrito Federal Superior Court. Similarly, on July 15, 1993, Mr. Alfonso Martín-del-Campo submitted his brief of grievances to the same Section. 58.1.17 On August 17, 1993, the Eighth Section of the Distrito Federal Superior Court confirmed the May 28, 1993, judgment handed down against Mr. Alfonso Martín-del-Campo and pointed out, concerning Mr. Martín-del-Campo’s Prosecutorial Agency deposition, that the latter was “the only relevant indication of evidence as to the solving of this case.” Similarly, the Court indicated that, while Mr. Martín-de-Campo declared before the judge that he had been physically pressured and gave another version of the events, said arguments were not “worthy of any recognition whatsoever as evidence since they contradicted the reality of the situation, in addition to the fact that they were discredited by pieces of conclusive evidence against him that had been already assessed.” 58.1.18 On June 18, 1997, Mr. Alfonso Martín-del-Campo filed a direct amparo appeal motion with the First Circuit Court against the judgment delivered by the Eighth Section of the Distrito Federal Superior Court on August 17, 1993, which had confirmed the firstinstance conviction. 58.1.19 On December 02, 1997, the Fourth Penal Court of the Distrito Federal First Circuit decided to deny “the protection of the federal justice requested by [Mr. Martín-del-Campo] against the decision of the Eighth Section of the Distrito Federal Superior Court, that he contested.” 58.1.20 On January 19, 1998, Mr. Alfonso Martín-del-Campo filed a revision remedy against the decision of the Fourth Penal Court of the Distrito Federal First Circuit delivered on December 02, 1997. On February 09, 1998, the First Section of the Supreme Court decided to dismiss such revision remedy as non applicable. 58.1.21 On July 13, 1998, Mr. Alfonso Martín-del-Campo denounced the facts of this case before the Inter-American Commission.

Select target paragraph3