29. The Commission indicated that the Merits Report identified 4,091 beneficiaries of the decision
of February 12 and that, within that group, a sub-group of 2,317 persons have continued to make
additional claims since March 2010. The Commission, therefore, considered that those persons were
identified as they were part of the group of 4,091 persons identified as alleged victims.
30. The Court preliminarily notes that, although the Commission refers to 4,091 alleged victims in
its Merits Report, it submitted a list that contained 4,043 alleged victims. 25 Moreover, the Court
observes that the representative Meneses Huayra included and accredited documentation on the
existence of another four alleged victims 26 who were not on the list transmitted by the Commission.
This is also true for 70 alleged victims whom the Court has verified as part of the group that
domestically litigated the non-compliance of the decision of February 12. 27 Pursuant to Article 35(2)
of the Rules, the Court considers that these 74 persons are also alleged victims.
31. With respect to the 30 persons whose exclusion was requested by the State, the Court observes
that there is no evidentiary documentation on 27 of them that accredits their condition as alleged
victims and, therefore, they should be excluded. 28 With respect to José Antonio Cirilo Crisóstomo
Bellaza, whose exclusion was also requested by the State, the Court notes that he was identified in
the record of the case, where it is noted that the State had made payments to him under the terms
of the decision of February 12. 29 Therefore, the petition to exclude must fail. Finally, with respect to
Andrés Ríos Soto and Alberto Carrasco, whom the State also requested to be excluded, the Court
notes that they were not included as alleged victims by the Commission. Thus, the number of alleged
victims is, in principle, 4,090, barring subsequent determinations in this judgment’s chapter on the
Merits.
32. Secondly, the Court observes that, as indicated by the Commission, the sub-group of 2,317
persons referred to by the State are part of the group of persons who have been identified as alleged
25
The final number was arrived at by excluding repeated names and he blank spaces that were on the list that was
consecutively numbered.
26
They are: Eloy Asunción Barrientos Espinosa, Wilfredo Jesús García Oballe, Leonardo Jesús Zuluoaga Cáceres and
Jorge Zuta Vásquez.
27
They are: Carlos Aguilar Mogollon, Guillermo Amaya Moreno, Humberto Araujo Miranda, Augusto Avila Augurto, Juan
Francisco Benites Gomez, Andres Avelino Carrascal Bellodas, Francisco Javier Castellano Rivandeneyra, Juan Manuel Castillo
Benavides, Miguel Jesus Castro Chunga, Roberto Castro Mena, Marcelino Castro Moran, Bernardo Chunga Alzamora, Nicolas
Alfredo Coronado Castro, Hermilio Eufracio Crisostomo Belleza, Fren Espinoza Farias, Norberto Segundo Farfan Cupen, Walter
Flores Chunga, Jorge G. Flores Jimenez, Felix Luciano Flores Macedo, Pedro Cesar Gil Nuñez, Pedro Gomez Alban, Francisco
Gomez Preciado, Ruben Grados Meza, Pablo Guillermo Soto, Manuel Hidalgo Rojas, Matias Incio Barboza, Francisco Izquierdo
Galan, Melecio Casimiro Lopez Marquez, Felix Alberto Lopez Rios, Tomas Mauricio Alamo, Eduardo Mauricio Peña, Jesus
Mauricio Peña, Manuel Mauricio Peña, Marcelino Mauricio Peña, Fidel Mogollon Neyra, Luis Jorge Morales Lopez, Anotnio
Emiliano Murillo Pacheco, Marcos Alberto Navarro Ayala, Ricardo Ysidro Pachas Almeryda, Luis Miguel Palomino Salazar, Jose
Esteban Paz Zapata, Manuel Natividad Pinday Monasterio, RaymundoPrieto Martinez, Pedro Alfonso Quevedo Silva, Victor
Hipolito Quinde Coronado, Jose Pedro Risco Vivas, Juan Manuel Rojas Reyes, Manuel Alberto Rosado Cobeñas, Julio Humberto
Rosado Galvez, Jose Rosado Taboada, Miguel Rueda Agurto, Arnulfo Ruiz Boulanger, Victor Luis Sancarro Oballe, Pedro
Sanjinez Saucedo, Fernando Renee Santa Cruz Salas, Manuel Ignacio Sernaque Farias, Manuel Alfredo Sotero Barriga, Carlos
Gerardo Timana Guarnizo, Carlos Alberto Torres Urbina, Jose Ponciano Valerio Rodriguez, Wilfredo Vargas Atoche, Higinio
Efren Vargas Benites, Carlos Enrique Vargas Coronado, Antonio Cesar Vasquez Landa, Martin Venegas Morales, Alejandro
Villacres Ramirez, Santos Victor Vivas Vargas, Pedro Adulfo Zapata Agurto, Pedro Orlando Zevallos Gamboa and Domingo
Bernardino Zapata Agurto.
28
They are: Jorge M.Aguilar Arana, Julio Aguilar Hernandez, Marco A.Angeldonis Alcazar, Pedro Aponte Ochoa, Felix
Baluarte Rojas, Abelardo Cardenas Goyoneche, Ernesto C.Casana Calderon, Jorge Cortez Martinez, Felix Curay Dioses, Luis
Farro Gonzales, Antonio Felipa Sanchez, Vicente Lopez Riega, Julio Padilla Torrico, Domingo Paiva Querebalu, Guillermo
Paniagua Vargas, Miguel Pastor Salazar, Freddy Peña Fuentes, Segundo Ramirez Chiroque, Andres Reyes Soto, Rolando Ruiz
Mendoza, Guillermo Salazar Hurtado, Servando Sanjinez Palacios, Fermin Segura Rojas, Ricardo Ugolini Murillo, Vicente
Valencia Nuñez, Jaime Vivanco Medina and Jesus Zevallos Solari.
29
Cf. List “Account of the duly identified former workers who were paid by the MEF, pursuant to the statement approved
by the Sixh Civil Court of Callao” (evidence file, fs. 55010 and ff.)
10