3 A. ARGUMENTS OF THE PARTIES AND OF THE COMMISSION ................................................................50 B. CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ............................................................................................51 B.1. Procedure to delimit, demarcate, and title the lands .......................................................52 B.2. Regulations and/or practices regarding the right to prior consultation...............................53 VII-3. THE RIGHT TO LIFE OF OSCAR BREGA, JESÚS ÁLVAREZ ROCHE, JORGE CASTILLO JIMÉNEZ AND JULIO ALBERTO MORALES (Article 4 of the Convention in relation to Article 1(1)) ................................................................................................................................... 54 A. ARGUMENTS OF THE PARTIES AND OF THE COMMISSION ................................................................54 B. CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ............................................................................................55 VII-4. RIGHT TO A FAIR TRIAL AND TO JUDICIAL PROTECTION (Article 8(1) and 25 of the Convention in relation to Articles 1(1) and 2) ..................................................................... 58 A. ARGUMENTS OF THE PARTIES AND OF THE COMMISSION ................................................................58 B. CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ............................................................................................61 B.1. The alleged lack of effectiveness of the remedies to obtain recognition of communal property ..........................................................................................................................62 B.2. The alleged lack of effectiveness of the judicial and administrative actions regarding the sales and allocations of traditional lands to third parties ................................................................64 B.3. The investigations related to the alleged threats and deaths against members of the Community of Triunfo de la Cruz ........................................................................................66 VIII. REPARATIONS (Application of Article 63(1) of the American Convention) ................. 66 A. INJURED PARTY .................................................................................................................67 B. MEASURES OF RESTITUTION: DEMARCATION AND TITLING OF LANDS ................................................67 C. OBLIGATION TO INVESTIGATE THAT FACTS THAT RESULTED IN THE VIOLATIONS AND IDENTIFY , JUDGE, AND, IF APPROPRIATE, PUNISH THOSE RESPONSIBLE ...............................................................................68 D. MEASURES OF SATISFACTION AND GUARANTEES OF NON-REPETITION ...............................................69 D.1. Measures of Satisfaction .............................................................................................69 D.2. Guarantees of non-repetition ......................................................................................70 E. F. G. H. COLLECTIVE COMPENSATION THROUGH A COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FUND ........................................72 COSTS AND EXPENSES ..........................................................................................................75 REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES TO THE LEGAL AID FUND FOR VICTIMS .............................................76 MEANS OF COMPLYING WITH THE PAYMENTS ORDERED .................................................................77 IX. OPERATIVE PARAGRAPHS ............................................................................................. 77 X. MAP ANNEX..................................................................................................................... 80 Humberto Antonio Sierra Porto ........................................................................................... 15 Judge .................................................................................................................................. 15 Pablo Saavedra Alessandri .................................................................................................. 15