family members. In the face of this situation, there have even been cases in which divers try
to commit suicide but are unable to succeed due to their condition.8
12.
The petitioners note that the Labor Code does not provide for the special
situation of workers in the fishing industry. The Occupational Health and Safety Regulation
for 2001 establishes the obligations of employers and workers in relation to the occupational
risks associated with fishing, guarantees occupational safety and accident prevention, and
sets different safety standards for vessels and for the various activities. 9 They indicate that
Honduran legislation provides for the resolution of labor conflicts between employers and
workers, administrative actions before the General Labor Bureau (Dirección General del
Trabajo)10, and judicial actions before the corresponding Labor Courts (Juzgados de
Trabajo)11, and must exhaust administrative remedies before availing themselves of judicial
remedies. They argue that in practice these mechanisms are not effective or adequate due to
the ineffectiveness of the actions of the judicial and administrative authorities.
13.
With respect to the exhaustion of domestic remedies, the petitioners indicate
that at least 30 persons turned to the administrative mechanisms, in some cases, and others
to judicial mechanisms, without any results whatsoever; the matters all got bogged down at
one or another stage of the procedure. They indicate that only Mr. Flaviano Martínez obtained
8 Testimony of Mr. Vismar Oracio, 29 years of age. He suffered decompression syndrome
when he was 20 years old in 1994; he was disabled, as he is unable to move his legs, and he
suffers from decubitus ulcer. “…mahka pruhan sinra lukisna…wan help ka apusna bara mahka
sin pruah aidokisa” “I think about suicide … not being able to fend for myself, I prefer to die.”
Petitioners’ brief of November 5, 2004.
9 Some of these obligations indicated in Article 7 of the Regulation are: To provide their
workers, free of charge, necessary and adequate diving equipment and equipment for
personal protection in keeping with the risks to which they are exposed, perform periodic
maintenance on the diving equipment, which should be replaced when completing its useful
life, as per the indications provided by the manufacturer; to immediately and adequately
transfer the workers from the fishing vessel to the closest hospital or medical center in case
of occupational hazard or other situation that affects the workers’ health; to adequately
instruct the workers before and during the performance of any work activity as to the risks
and hazards they may face, as well as the method for preventing them; to enter into an
individual labor contract with each of the workers, approved by the Ministry of Labor and
Social Security; to see to it that the workers do not perform their work under the influence of
narcotic drugs or alcohol. Petitioners’ brief of December 18, 2007, p. 5.
10 The Labor Code does not establish a clear procedure for administrative conciliation
procedures. In practice, the worker affected goes before the offices of the General Labor
Bureau located in Tegucigalpa, Puerto Lempira, La Ceiba, and Roatán. Once he presents the
labor claim, if it arises from an occupational hazard the worker is referred to the Medical
Evaluation Unit, where the calculation of the corresponding compensation is done. The
employer is called to a hearing to make the corresponding payment; if the employer does not
appear, a certificate is issued to the worker so he can pursue the matter judicially. Petitioners’
brief of December 18, 2007, p. 6.
11 There is no Labor Court in the department of Gracias a Dios. Honduras has a total of 83
courts known as juzgados de Letras for the 18 departments into which the country is divided;
only one of these is in Gracias a Dios, in Puerto Lempira. Petitioners’ brief of December 18,
2007, p. 9.
See United Nations Development Program, Segundo Informe sobre Desarrollo Humano en
Centroamérica
y
Panamá,
Capítulo
Desafío
de
la
Calidad
Democrática.
http://www.estadonacion.or.cr/Region2003/Paginas/ponencias/Adm_Justicia_HON.pdf
[Consulted: May 22, 2009].