3
preliminary objection of non-exhaustion of domestic remedies and asked the
Commission to consider its participation in the friendly settlement negotiations to
be at an end.
7.
At the petitioner's request, another hearing was held on February
1995, at which, according to the Commission, Guatemala again rejected
proposal of a friendly settlement of the case, submitted a new report of
proceedings in progress in the domestic courts, and once more invoked
objection of non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
14,
the
the
the
8.
On February 15, 1995, the Commission approved Report No. 5/95, and
decided in its operative part:
TO RECOMMEND
1.
That the State of Guatemala accept its objective responsibility for the murder
of Mr. Nicholas Blake, his disappearance and the cover-up of his murder; and make
the appropriate reparations to his successors;
2.
That the State of Guatemala, on the basis of evidence already in existence
and evidence obtainable under its legislation, identify, prosecute, detain and punish
those responsible for the death of Mr. Nicholas Blake;
3.
That the State of Guatemala, on the basis of evidence already in existence
and evidence obtainable under its legislation, identify, prosecute, detain and punish
those responsible for the cover-up and obstruction of the judicial proceedings
concerning the disappearance and death of Mr. Nicholas Blake;
4.
That the State of Guatemala take such measures as are necessary to avoid a
recurrence of such types of violation, including abuses by the Civil Patrols, cover-ups
by civilian and military authorities, and the lack of effective judicial proceedings;
5.
That this report, drawn up in accordance with Article 50, be transmitted to
the Government, which shall not be at liberty to publish it, and
6.
That if within a period of sixty days from the transmittal of this Report, the
Government has not implemented the above recommendations, the instant case be
submitted to the Inter-American Court of Human Rights pursuant to Article 51 of the
American Convention.
9.
On May 4, 1995, the Commission transmitted Report No. 5/95 to
Guatemala, informing it that if it failed to implement the recommendations
contained therein, the Commission would submit the case for the consideration of
the Inter-American Court, as provided in Article 51 of the Convention.
10.
On July 5, 1995, the Government transmitted its reply to the Commission,
declaring that:
[t]he proceedings on the merits are currently at the investigation stage, the last
procedural steps being the statements by witnesses in the instant case before the
District Prosecutor of the Ministry of the Interior ["Ministerio Público] of
Huehuetenango... [and a]s indicated by the statements made by the aforementioned
persons, it is evident that the case is progressing.
11.
On August 3, 1995, having not reached an agreement with the
Government, the Commission submitted the case for the consideration and
decision of the Court.
IV
PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE COURT