and took their oath.158 That same day the first documentary evidence was received, consisting of the report submitted by Club Ciudadela Norte.159 Also, on March 6, 1998 the Escuela Técnica No. 4 reported on Sebastián Furlan’s performance at school during the academic years before and after his accident.160 On April 6, 1998 the Chief of Police Station 45 of the Argentinean Federal Police, forwarded a record referring to one of Sebastián Furlan’s detentions after the accident.161 92. Between August 19 and 20, 1998 the court received the testimony of five of the eight witnesses called by the petitioner’s attorney.162 On August 20, 1998 the attorney waived the testimony the other three witnesses.163 93. On August 14, 1998 the attorney issued a communication to EMGE asking it to submit all administrative records related to Sebastián Furlan’s proceedings.164 On November 12, 1998 the Chief of the General Archives of the Army informed the court that no record relating to Sebastián Furlan appeared in the records of any of the different offices of the Army.165 158 Cf. Certificates issued by the Federal Judge of First Instance on March 2, 1998 (file of appendices to the report, volume I, appendix 6, page 243). 159 Cf. Brief issued by Club Ciudadela Norte, page 244. 160 Cf. Brief issued by Escuela de Education Técnica No. 4, supra note 96, page 249. 161 Cf. Brief issued by Police Station No. 15 Federal Police of Argentina of April 6, 1998 (file of appendices to the report, volume I, appendix 6, page 346). 162 Cf. Transcript of the statement by Leonardo Javier Occhiuzzi of August 19, 1998; transcript of the statement by Rubén Guerrero of August 19, 1998; transcript of the statement by Jorge Omar Praderio of August 20, 1998; transcript of the statement by Osvaldo Roberto Sotomayor of August 20, 1998, and transcript of the statement by Gabriel Osvaldo Lacasa of August 20, 1998 (file of appendices to the report, volume I appendix 6, pages 371 to 380). Regarding Sebastián Furlan’s general situation prior to the accident, his neighbors and friends were consistent in indicating that he was a normal kid, keen on sports and he attended school. The statement of August 19, 1998 by Leonardo Javier Occhiuzzi, “neighbor and friend,” indicates “that [at the time of the accident Sebastián] was a student and practiced sports […] he played basketball. Nevertheless he pointed out that Sebastián “was in a bad state of mind at the time of accident as well as immediately afterwards.” Jorge Omar Praderio emphasized that “before [the accident Sebastián] was a normal kid.” Similarly, Gabriel Osvaldo Lacasa stated in his testimony that “before the accident [Sebastián] played soccer, volleyball, went swimming, and did as many sports as he could [and] also studied.” Regarding the consequences of the accident, the witnesses described a general deterioration of Sebastián’s functions. Leonardo Javier Occhiuzzi stated that at the time of the statement Sebastián “[had] motor, coordination and speech problems […] he kn[ew]this because [he was] his neighbor” and “liv[ed] opposite [his] house.” Moreover, in his statement of August 19, 1998 Rubén Guerrero explained that “when he spok[e] and walk[ed] it was noticeable that he was not normal” and that right after the accident “the father helped him along because he could not walk.” Similarly, Jorge Omar Praderio gave testimony August 20, 1998, pointing out that Sebastián “[had] difficulties of speech, sometimes lost his memory, he got [lost] and the father [had] to go look for him.” He said that at the time of the statement Sebastián [was] in very bad state, he realiz[ed] that he could not get a good job[and that] he [was] not normal.” Osvaldo Roberto Sotomayor stated that after the accident Sebastián was “always in a bad state, even now […] he cannot find a job [and] cannot finish studying.” Likewise, Gabriel Osvaldo pointed out that “after the accident he would leave, disappear, and the father had to go look for him around the neighborhood […] if he saw someone it [was] like if he didn’t recognize them.” He added that, as of the time of this statement, “he does not seem to be well, he c[ould] not hold a conversation, [and] that he was like a four or five year old kid.” 163 Cf. Brief of the attorney of Sebastián Furlan of August 20, 1998 (file of appendices to the report, volume I, appendix 6, page 381). 164 Cf. Communication issued by secretary 18 of the National Civil and Federal Commercial Court No.9 of August 14, 1998 (file of appendices to the report, volume I, appendix 6, page 470). 165 Cf. Communication of the Argentine Army of November 12, 1998 (file of appendices to the report, volume I, appendix 6, page 479). 31

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents