44
Judge Medina Quiroga, Judge May Macaulay, and Judge Rodríguez-Pinzón, all dissent.
Unanimously, that
5.
The State shall pay the amount established in paragraph 112 of the present Judgment
for non-pecuniary damages, in the period and terms mentioned in paragraphs 109 to 111 and
113 of this Judgment.
Unanimously, that,
6.
The State shall pay the amounts established in paragraph 141 of the present
Judgment for reimbursement of costs and expenses, in the period and terms mentioned in
paragraph 140 of this Judgment.
Unanimously, that,
7.
The State must refund to Mrs. Mary Salvador Chiriboga, as a measure of restitution, the
amount indicated in paragraph 124 for property taxes, additional charges, and other duties as
well as surcharges on plots without constructions that were wrongfully collected, as well as the
corresponding interests, within a six-month term, pursuant with that stated in the mentioned
paragraph of the Judgment.
Unanimously, that,
8.
The State must carry out the publications ordered in paragraph 127 of the present
judgment, in the period and terms indicated in the mentioned paragraph.
Unanimously, that,
9.
Within a one-year term computed as of the notification of this Judgment and to the
effects of monitoring its compliance, the State must deliver to the Tribunal a report on the
measures adopted in this sense. The Court will consider the present case closed once the State
has fully complied with that ordered in this Judgment.
Judge García-Sayán, Judge Medina Quiroga, Judge García Ramírez, Judge L. Franco, Judge
May Macaulay, and Judge ad hoc Rodríguez Pinzón informed the Court of their Partially
Dissenting Opinions. Said Opinions are attached to this Judgment.
Written in Spanish and in English, the Spanish text being authentic, in San Jose, Costa Rica on
March 3, 2011.
Diego García-Sayán
President
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents