10
e)
As a result of the facts that prompted this case, Luis Alberto Cantoral
Benavides has had –and still has- physical and psychiatric health problems;18
f)
Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides received psychiatric treatment under a
special program run by the National Coordinator of Human Rights
[Coordinadora Nacional de Derechos Humanos] (CNDDHH) in Lima, Peru. He
has also received psychotherapy in Brazil;19
g)
Mrs. Gladys Benavides López, the victim’s mother, suffered pecuniary
and non-pecuniary damages caused by the facts of the case,20 and suffered
from various ailments requiring physical and psychiatric care; she herself had
to defray the expense of her medications;21
h)
Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides’ brothers suffered pecuniary and nonpecuniary damages caused by the events of this case;22 and
delivered on August 18, 2000, paragraph 63 e), f), g), i), j), and k); and documents verifying expenses,
in Appendix 19 of the evidence tendered by the victim’s representatives.
18
Cf. expert report of Ana Luiza Loureiro de Vasconcellos, submitted to the Court on September 6,
2001, at the public hearing on reparations in the present case; expert report of Oscar Maldonado
Fernández, submitted to the Court on September 6, 2001, at the public hearing on reparations in the
present case; Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides’ testimony to the Court on September 6, 2001, at the public
hearing on reparations in the present case; Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides’ testimony to the Court on
September 20, 1999, at the public hearing on the merits of the present case; Gladys Benavides López’
testimony to the Court on September 6, 2001, at the public hearing on reparations in the present case;
February 28, 2001 psychological report prepared by Ana Luiza Loureiro de Vasconcellos on Luis Alberto
Cantoral Benavides; December 19, 2000 psychological report on Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides,
prepared by team coordinator Carmen Wurst and psychotherapist Oscar Maldonado from the program to
assist victims of torture and human rights violations of the Office of the National Coordinator of Human
Rights of Peru.; and handwritten notes from Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides and Luis Fernando Cantoral
Benavides to their mother, at appendices 7, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 of the evidence on reparations tendered
by the victim’s representatives.
19
Cf. December 19, 2000 psychological report on Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides, prepared by
team coordinator Carmen Wurst and psychotherapist Oscar Maldonado from the program to assist victims
of torture and human rights violations of the Office of the National Coordinator of Human Rights of Peru;
expert report by Oscar Maldonado Fernández and submitted to the Court on September 6, 2001, at the
public hearing on reparations in the present case; February 28, 2001 psychological report prepared by Ana
Luiza Loureiro de Vasconcellos on Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides; expert report prepared by Ana Luiza
Laureiro de Vasconcellos and submitted to the Court on September 6, 2001, at the public hearing on
reparations in the present case; and Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides’ testimony to the Court on
September 6, 2001, at the public hearing on reparations in the present case.
20
Cf. Gladys Benavides López’ testimony to the Court on September 6, 2001, at the public hearing
on reparations in the present case; Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides’ testimony to the Court on September
6, 2001, at the public hearing on reparations in the present case; and Eloy Urso Cantoral Huamaní’s
testimony to the Court on September 6, 2001, at the public hearing on reparations in the present case.
21
Cf. November 15, 1999 memorandum from the Executive Director of FEDEPAZ to the Director of
the Health Ministry’s Hospital Nacional “Dos de Mayo”; certificate dated October 27, 1999, issued by the
Psychology Clinic of the Mental Health Service of the Health Ministry’s Hospital Nacional “Dos de Mayo”;
memorandum no. 1905-99-DG-HNDM, dated November 29, 1999, from the Director General of the Health
Ministry’s Hospital Nacional “Dos de Mayo”, to the Executive Director of FEDEPAZ; and documents
verifying expenses, in appendices 25, 26 and 47 of the evidence on reparations tendered by the victim’s
representatives.
22
Cf. Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides’ testimony to the Court on September 6, 2001, at the public
hearing on reparations in the present case; Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides’ testimony to the Court on
September 20, 1999, at the public hearing on the merits of the present case; Gladys Benavides López’
testimony to the Court on September 6, 2001, at the public hearing on reparations in the present case;
handwritten notes from Luis Alberto Cantoral Benavides and Luis Fernando Cantoral Benavides to their
mother, in appendices 7, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13 of the evidence on reparations tendered by the victim’s