B.2.2. Rights to freedom of movement and residence, to judicial guarantees and to
judicial protection ........................................................................................ 123
B.2.2.1. Collective expulsions of Haitian nationals (Article 22(9)).................... 123
B.2.2.2. The expulsions and the alleged violation of the freedom of movement and
residence of the Dominican nationals (Articles 22(1) and 22(5)) ..................... 124
B.2.2.3. Respect for the basic procedural guarantees (Article 8(1)) ................. 125
B.2.2.4. The existence of an effective remedy to contest the detention and
expulsion (Article 25(1)) ............................................................................ 126
B.2.3. The discriminatory nature of the expulsions (Article 1(1)) ....................... 127
B.3. Conclusion .............................................................................................. 129
X RIGHT TO THE PROTECTION OF PRIVACY AND RIGHTS OF THE FAMILY IN
RELATION TO THE RIGHTS OF THE CHILD AND THE OBLIGATION TO RESPECT
RIGHTS ......................................................................................................... 12130
A) ARGUMENTS OF THE COMMISSION AND OF THE PARTIES .......................................... 130
B) CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ....................................................................... 131
B.1. Family separation (Article 17(1)) ............................................................... 131
B.2. Interference in the family home (Article 11(2)) ........................................... 135
B.3. Conclusion .............................................................................................. 136
XI RIGHT TO PERSONAL INTEGRITY ................................................................. 137
A) ARGUMENTS OF THE COMMISSION AND OF THE PARTIES .......................................... 137
B) CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ....................................................................... 139
XII RIGHT TO PROPERTY .................................................................................. 139
A) ARGUMENTS OF THE COMMISSION AND OF THE PARTIES .......................................... 139
B) CONSIDERATIONS OF THE COURT ....................................................................... 140
XIII REPARATIONS ........................................................................................... 140
A) INJURED PARTY ............................................................................................. 141
B) MEASURES OF INTEGRAL REPARATION: RESTITUTION, SATISFACTION, AND GUARANTEES OF
NON-REPETITION ................................................................................................ 141
B.1. Measures of restitution ............................................................................. 141
B.1.1. Recognition of nationality to the Dominicans and residence permits for the
Haitians ..................................................................................................... 142
B.1.1.1. Willian Medina Ferreras and the members of his family ..................... 142
B.1.1.2. Victor Jean, Miguel Jean, Victoria Jean and Natalie Jean .................... 144
B.1.1.3. Marlene Mesidor ........................................................................... 144
B.2. Measures of satisfaction ........................................................................... 144
B.2.1. Publication of the Judgment ................................................................ 144
B.3. Guarantees of non-repetition .................................................................... 144
B.3.1. Human rights training for State agents ................................................. 145
B.3.2. Adoption of domestic legal measures .................................................... 146
B.3.4. Other measures ................................................................................. 147
B.3.5. Other measures requested .................................................................. 147
C) REPARATIONS FOR PECUNIARY AND NON-PECUNIARY DAMAGE .................................. 148
C.1. Pecuniary damage ................................................................................... 148
C.2. Non-pecuniary damage ............................................................................ 149
D) COSTS AND EXPENSES ..................................................................................... 151
E) REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES TO THE VICTIMS’ LEGAL ASSISTANCE FUND ................. 154
F) METHOD OF COMPLYING WITH THE PAYMENTS ORDERED .......................................... 155
XIV OPERATIVE PARAGRAPHS .......................................................................... 155
4