89 By a unanimous vote, that: 1. It accepts the partial recognition of international responsibility effectuated by the State for the events of January 18, 1989, according to the corresponding terms of paragraphs 8 to 54 of the present Judgment. 2. The State violated the right to life enshrined in Article 4 of the American Convention on Human Rights, in relation to Article 1(1) of the same, to the detriment of Mariela Morales Caro, Pablo Antonio Beltrán Palomino, Virgilio Hernández Serrano, Carlos Fernando Castillo Zapata, Luis Orlando Hernández Muñoz, Yul Germán Monroy Ramírez, Gabriel Enrique Vesga Fonseca, Benhur Iván Guasca Castro, Orlando Morales Cárdenas, César Augusto Morales Cepeda, Arnulfo Mejía Duarte, Samuel Vargas Páez, Arturo Salgado Garzón, Wilson Humberto Mantilla Castilla and Manuel Libardo Díaz Navas, in the corresponding terms expressed in paragraphs 66 to 103, 123 to 128 and 140 of the present Judgment. 3. The State violated the right to personal integrity enshrined in Article 5(1) and 5(2) of the American Convention on Human Rights, in relation to Article 1(1) of the same, to the detriment of Mariela Morales Caro, Pablo Antonio Beltrán Palomino, Virgilio Hernández Serrano, Carlos Fernando Castillo Zapata, Luis Orlando Hernández Muñoz, Yul Germán Monroy Ramírez, Gabriel Enrique Vesga Fonseca, Benhur Iván Guasca Castro, Orlando Morales Cárdenas, César Augusto Morales Cepeda, Arnulfo Mejía Duarte, Samuel Vargas Páez, Arturo Salgado Garzón, Wilson Humberto Mantilla Castilla and Manuel Libardo Díaz Navas, in the corresponding terms expressed in paragraphs 66 to 103, 129 to 136 and 140 of the present Judgment. 4. The State violated the right to personal liberty enshrined in Article 7 of the American Convention on Human Rights, in relation to Article 1(1) of the same, to the detriment of Mariela Morales Caro, Pablo Antonio Beltrán Palomino, Virgilio Hernández Serrano, Carlos Fernando Castillo Zapata, Luis Orlando Hernández Muñoz, Yul Germán Monroy Ramírez, Gabriel Enrique Vesga Fonseca, Benhur Iván Guasca Castro, Orlando Morales Cárdenas, César Augusto Morales Cepeda, Arnulfo Mejía Duarte, Samuel Vargas Páez, Arturo Salgado Garzón, Wilson Humberto Mantilla Castilla and Manuel Libardo Díaz Navas, in the corresponding terms expressed in paragraphs 66 to 103, 122 and 140 of the present Judgment. 5. The State violated the right to personal integrity enshrined in Article 5 of the American Convention on Human Rights, in relation to Article 1(1) of the same, to the detriment of the next of kin of the victims identified in the Appendix of the present Judgment, that for this purpose serves as part of the Judgment, in corresponding terms expressed in paragraphs 66 to 103, 137 to 139 and 141 of the same. 6. The State violated the right to a fair trial and judicial protection enshrined in Articles 8(1) and 25 of the American Convention on Human Rights, in relation to Article 1.1 of the same, to the detriment of the surviving victims Arturo Salgado Garzón, Wilson Humberto Mantilla Castilla and Manuel Libardo Díaz Navas, and the next of kin of the deceased victims identified in the Appendix of the present Judgment, that for this purpose, serves as part of the Judgment in the terms identified in paragraphs 142 to 225 of this Judgment. 7. This Judgment constitutes per se a form of reparation.