par excellence (beyond the formal sources) of the whole law of nations (droit des
gens), responsible for the advances of the human kind not only at the juridical level
but also at the spiritual one. What survives us is only the creation of our spirit, to the
effect of elevating the human condition. This is how I conceive the legacy of the
dead, from a perspective of human rights.
17.
This spiritual dimension - of the universal juridical conscience - has found
expression in distinct international instruments of protection of the rights of the
human person: pertinent illustrations are found, e.g., in the preambles of the
American Declaration on the Rights and Duties of Man (1948), of the Convention
against Genocide (1948), of the Inter-American Convention on Forced Disappearance
of Persons (1994), of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (1998), besides the well-known Martens clause (with its evocation to the "laws of humanity"
and to the "dictates of the public conscience"), set forth repeatedly in successive
instruments of International Humanitarian Law12.
18.
It is significant that the Inter-American Convention on Forced Disappearance
of Persons (1994) warns in its preamble that "the systematic practice of the forced
disappearance of persons constitutes a crime against humanity"13. This expression
has a juridical content of its own and a strong semantic weight, seeming to
conceptualize humanity itself as subject of law. The doctrinal conceptualization of the
so-called crimes against humanity, - victimizing in massive scale human beings, in
their spirit and in their body, - has its origins, well before the Convention against
Genocide of 1948, in customary international law itself, on the basis of fundamental
notions of humanity and of the dictates of the public conscience 14.
III.
The Links of Solidarity between the Dead and the Living.
19.
The respect to the memory of the dead in the persons of the living constitutes
one of the aspects of human solidarity that links the living to those who have already
died. The respect to the mortal remains is also due to the spirit which animated in
life the dead person, in connection moreover with the beliefs of the survivors as to
the destiny post mortem of the person who died15. It cannot be denied that the
death of an individual affects directly the life, as well as the juridical situation, of
other individuals, especially his relatives (as illustrated, in the frameword of civil law
(droit civil), by the norms of family law and the law of successions).
20.
In the face of the anguish generated by the death of a beloved person, the
burial rites, with the mortal remains, purport to bring a minimum of consolation to
the survivors. Hence the importance of the respect for the mortal remains: their
hiding deprives the relatives also of the burial ritual, which fulfils the needs of the
unconscious itself and nourishes the hope in the prolongation or permanence of
being16 (even though only in the live memory and in the links of affection of the
12
.
E.g., Hague Conventions of 1899 and 1907 (preambles), Geneva Conventions of 1949 on
International Humanitarian Law (preambles), Additional Protocol I of 1977 (Article 1) to the Geneva
Conventions of 1949, Aditional Protocol II (in simplified form, in the preamble, considerandum 4).
13
.
Paragraph 6 (emphasis added).
14
.
For an account, cf., e.g., S.R. Ratner and J.S. Abrams, Accountability for Human Rights Atrocities
in International Law, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1997, pp. 45-77.
15
.
B. Py, op. cit. supra n. (8), pp. 94 and 77, and cf. pp. 7, 38, 47, 77 and 123.
16
.
L.-V. Thomas, La mort, 4th. corr. ed., Paris, PUF, 1998, pp. 91-93, 107, 113 and 115.