Jorge Franclin Cuarán Muchavisoy (brother)
US $4,000.00
Next of kin of Artemio Pantoja Ordónez
María Adelina López (mother)
US $6,000.00
Carmen Lidia Pantoja López (daughter)
US $6,000.00
Carmen Leonor Pantoja López (daughter)
US $8,000.00
Aura Esperanza Pantoja López (daughter)
US $6,000.00
Miriam Lucy Pantoja López (daughter)
US $6,000.00
Adali Oneyda Pantoja López (daughter)
US $6,000.00
Ramiro Artemio Pantoja López (son)
US $6,000.00
Jaime Pantoja López (son)
US $6,000.00
Segundo Jorge Pantoja Moreno (father)
US $6,000.00
Pastora Ordóñez (mother)
US $6,000.00
Luis Edmundo Pantoja Ordóñez (brother)
US $4,000.00
Pecuniary reparations
Next of kin of Julio Milciades Cerón Gómez,
Wilian Hamilton Cerón Rojas, and Edebraes
Norverto Cerón Rojas
Yaneida Violeta Cerón Vargas (niece)
Amount
US $6,000.00
58.
The Court set the compensations stated in the foregoing tables, taking into
account the specific situations of those entitled to reparations and the evidence
included in the body of evidence. In the case of Blanca Flor Rojas, since she is a
victim of denial of justice as a spouse and as a mother, this double category was
taken into account when reparation was determined. On the other hand, the
children or siblings of the victims who demonstrated that their detriment worsened
due to interruption of the labor contract, problems in their interpersonal relations,
and detainments, among others, were granted larger indemnifications than other
children or siblings. The Court took into account detriment to labor relations when it
determined said compensation, even though the representatives of the next of kin of
the victims and the Commission only referred to non-pecuniary damage. Finally,
Yaneida Violeta Cerón Vargas, a niece of one of the victims, was granted equal
reparation to that granted to the children of the victims, because she proved that
since she was six she lived in the household of Julio Milciades Cerón Gómez and that
she has close ties with said family.
59.
The December 6, 2001 judgment also states that Colombia must indemnify
the next of kin of Hernán Lizcano Jacanamijoy. This person was killed in the events
at Las Palmeras, but it was not proven that his death was attributable to the State in
violation of Article 4 of the American Convention. The State, in turn, did not
demonstrate that Lizcano Jacanamijoy was a guerrilla fighter. Therefore, Colombia
did not have the right to treat him as such. Allegations that he was a guerrilla
fighter have offended the next of kin of Lizcano Jacanamijoy. Therefore, his parents,
children and permanent companion have the right to compensation, as do the next
of kin who testified before the Court or submitted their statement made before a
notary public.
60.
The pecuniary reparations are as follows:
Pecuniary reparations
Next of kin of Hernán Lizcano Jacanamijoy
Inés Sigindioy Narvaez (permanent companion)
Amount
US $6,000.00
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents