1. In accordance with the provisions stipulated in Considering Paragraphs 9 and 12 of this Order, the State has fully complied with the operative paragraphs of the Judgment delivered in the instant case which ordered the State: a) to pay Arlei José Escher, Dalton Luciano de Vargas, Delfino José Becker, Pedro Alves Cabral and Celso Aghinoni, the amount established in paragraph 235 of the […] Judgment for non-pecuniary damage, within one year of notification thereof and as stipulated in paragraphs 260 to 264 of the Judgment (Operative Paragraph 7 of the Judgment of July 9, 2009); b) to publish once in the Official Gazette, in another national newspaper with widespread circulation, and in a newspaper with widespread circulation in the state de Paraná, the cover page, Chapters I, VI to XI, without the corresponding footnotes, and the operative paragraphs of the […] Judgment, and to publish the entire text of the […] Judgment on an official web page of the Federal State and of the state of Paraná. The publications in the newspapers and on the Internet must be made within six and twelve months, respectively, of notification of the Judgment, under the terms of paragraph 239 thereof (Operative Paragraph 8 of the Judgment of July 9, 2009), and c) to pay the amount established in paragraph 259 of the […] Judgment for reimbursement of costs and expenses, within one year of notification thereof and as stipulated in paragraphs 260 to 264 of the Judgment (Operative Paragraph 10 of the Judgment of July 9, 2009). 2. Likewise, according to the provisions of Considering paragraphs 16 to 21 of this Order, it proceeds to close the procedure to monitor compliance with the following operative paragraph of the Judgment, which ordered the State: a) To investigate the facts that gave rise to the violations in the instant case, as stipulated in paragraph 247 of the Judgment (Operative Paragraph 9 of the Judgment of July 9, 2009). AND DECIDES: 1. To consider closed the case of Escher et al, given that the State of complied with the measures ordered in Operative Paragraphs 7, 8 and Judgment delivered by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights on July 9, also of the procedure to monitor compliance with Operative Paragraph Judgment. 2. Brazil has 10 of the 2009, and 9 of said To archive the case file in the instant case. 3. To communicate this Order to the General Assembly of the Organization of American States during its next period of regular sessions by means of the Annual Report of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights for the year 2012. 8

Select target paragraph3