in order to protect against any unlawful or arbitrary interference with physical liberty.200
Otherwise, the rights established in Articles 7(1) and 7(2) of the American Convention, in
relation to Article 1(1) of this instrument, are violated.201
198. The deprivation of liberty which initiates a forced disappearance, whatever form it
takes, is contrary to Article 7 of the American Convention. In the instant case, the Court
noted that the 26 victims were disappeared between September 22, 1983, and March 2,
1985.
199. According to the entries in the Diario Militar, which include the date of capture and of
presumed execution, 12 victims were detained from 15 to 40 days; Otto René Estrada
Illescas was detained for 79 days, and Orencio Calderón Sosa for 106 days, while Ruben
Amílcar Farfán was presumably executed the day of his capture, even though his remains
have not been found or identified.202 According to the Diario Militar, the remaining victims,
whose entries include relevant dates, were sent to other detention centers, after at least
five days of captivity, or to other unknown destinations.203 Specifically, frequently
transferring detainees to unofficial detention centers was a practice noted during the armed
conflict,204 with the purpose of “erasing the traces of the victims, precluding any possible
legal action by removing the detainees from access to justice and the care of their family;
[as well as] to take them to special interrogation centers.”205 This Court considers that the
detention of the 26 presumed victims involved a violation of their liberty, in the broadest
possible sense of Article 7(1) of the Convention, because, after more than 25 years, the
whereabouts of 24 of the 26 victims are unknown.
200. In addition, with regard to the right to personal liberty and persons deprived of
liberty, the Court has recognized that the State is in a special position as guarantor of the
rights of those detained,206 so that the deprivation of liberty in legally recognized centers
and the existence of records of detainees constitute fundamental safeguards, inter alia,
200
Cf. Case of Chaparro Álvarez and Lapo Íñiguez v. Ecuador. Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and
costs. Judgment of November 21, 2007. Series C No. 170, para. 53, and Case of González Medina and family
members v. Dominican Republic, supra, para. 178.
201
Cf. Case of Chaparro Álvarez and Lapo Íñiguez v. Ecuador, supra, para. 54, and Case of González Medina
and family members v. Dominican Republic, supra, para. 178.
202
The 12 victims who remained in captivity from 15 to 60 days are: Sergio Leonel Alvarado Arévalo, Alfonso
Alvarado Palencia, Oscar Eduardo Barillas Barrientos, Álvaro Zacarías Calvo Pérez, Félix Estrada Mejía, Octavio
René Guzmán Castañeda, Crescencio Gómez López, José Porfirio Hernández Bonilla, Sergio Saúl Linares Morales,
Carlos Guillermo Ramírez Gálvez, Manuel Ismael Salanic Chiguil and Amancio Samuel Villatoro.
203
These victims are: Joaquín Rodas Andrade, José Miguel Gudiel Álvarez, Luz Haydée Méndez Calderón, Luis
Rolando Peñate Lima, Juan Pablo Armira López and María Quirina Armira López. Cf. Diario Militar, supra, folios 357,
380, 386, 409 and 406. According to the Report of the Peace Secretariat on the Diario Militar, when this document
indicates “Transferred to U-4” (such as in the entry for Luz Haydée Méndez Calderón) “apparently this refers to a
military unit.” In addition, according to Katharine Doyle, the annotation “D.I.” (indicated in the entry for Luis
Rolando Peñate Lima) refers to the Intelligence Directorate, while “S-2” refers to a branch of military intelligence.
Cf. Peace Secretariat, supra, p. 112, and expert opinion provided by Katharine Doyle before the Inter-American
Commission on Human Rights at the public hearing on October 12, 2007, annex 2 of the merits report, available at
http://www.oas.org/es/IACHR/audiencias/Hearings.aspx?Lang=es&Session=13.
204
Cf. CEH, supra, volume II, p. 421, para. 2082, and Human Rights Office of the Archbishopric of Guatemala
(ODHAG), Guatemala Nunca Más. Informe del Proyecto Interdiocesano “Recuperación de la Memoria Histórica,
1998, tome II, Chapter 2, p. 53 (file of the proceedings before the Commission, Annexes, tome I, folio 3540).
205
Cf. CEH, supra, volume II, p. 421, para. 2083.
206
Cf. Case of Neira Alegría et al. v. Peru. Merits. Judgment of January 19, 1995. Series C No. 20, para. 60,
and Case of González Medina and family members v. Dominican Republic, supra, para. 177.
- 67 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents