368. International case law has repeatedly established that the judgment constitutes, per se, a form of reparation.437 Nevertheless, in its case law, the Court has developed the concept of non-pecuniary damage and has established that it may include the suffering and distress caused to the direct victims and their families, the impairment of values that are of great significance to them, as well as the alterations, of a non-pecuniary nature, in the living conditions of the victims or their family.438 369. The representatives asked the Court to order the State to repair the non-pecuniary damage relating to “the effects suffered by the victims.” Specifically, they asked that, pursuant to the Court’s case law, “in equity,” it order Guatemala to pay the following amounts: (i) US$100,000.00 (one hundred thousand United States dollars) to each victim; (ii) US$65,000.00 (sixty-five thousand United States dollars) to each member of the immediate family, and (iii) US$20,000.00 (twenty thousand United States dollars) to each indirect family member for the non-pecuniary damage suffered as a result of the facts.439 In this regard, they indicated that, in other cases, the Court had taken into account the characteristic of “double condition of victim”; hence, they considered that the compensation should not be paid by family group. Additionally, they asked that “the compensation ordered in this Judgment should not prevent any reparations that might, eventually, be ordered under domestic law. For its part, in its answering brief, the State expressed its “willingness to pay financial compensation to the next of kin of the victims in this case for the violations suffered.” However, it noted that “the amounts requested […] are too high, taking into account the financial situation of the country.” Therefore, it considered that the Court should consider establishing “an amount of Q. 200,000.00 for each family unit” in order “to cover the amount for the non-pecuniary damage suffered.”440 370. Considering the circumstances of the case sub judice, the sufferings that the violations committed caused to the victims, as well as the alteration in their living conditions and the other consequences of an intangible or non-pecuniary nature that they suffered, the Court finds it pertinent to establish an amount, in equity, as compensation for nonpecuniary damage. 371. Based on the compensation ordered by the Court in other cases relating to the forced disappearance of persons, as well as the circumstances of this case, the magnitude, nature and gravity of the violations committed, the sufferings caused to the victims and their next of kin, the time that has passed since the disappearances began and the denial of justice, and the impunity of the facts for more than 25 years, the Court finds it appropriate to establish, in equity, the sum of US$80,000.00 (eighty thousand United States dollars) in favor of the 26 victims of forced disappearances; US$40,000.00 (forty thousand United 437 Cf. Case of El Amparo v. Venezuela. Reparations and costs. Judgment of September 14, 1996. Series C No. 28, para. 35, and Case of the Massacres of El Mozote and nearby places v. El Salvador, supra, para. 382. 438 Case of the “Street Children” (Villagrán Morales et al.) v. Guatemala. Reparations and costs, Judgment of May 26, 2001. Series C No. 77, para. 84, and Case of the Massacres of El Mozote and nearby places v. El Salvador, supra, para. 382. 439 The representatives asked that, in order to determine the non-pecuniary damage suffered by the next of kin, the Court take into account: (i) “the harm suffered […] due to the threats, harassment and attempts on their life after the […] facts”; (ii) that “some of them […] were forcibly displaced from their place of residence”; (iii) that “they were subjected to all kinds of harassment, discrimination and stigmatization”; (iv) “the ostensible reduction in their physical, mental and material quality of life”; (v) the “feelings of anguish and helplessness as a result of the denial of justice and the impossibility, to date, of knowing the whereabouts of the disappeared,” and (vi) the concealment by the State of “official documents [on] the circumstances of the disappearances, as well as the involvement of State agents” which has “increased their suffering and anguish.” 440 In its brief with final arguments, the State indicated “that to cover the amount for non-pecuniary damage suffered, the […] Court should consider establishing the sum of Q.200,000.00 for each family unit affected.” - 124 -

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents