203. Regarding Article 5 of the American Convention, this Court has maintained that
forced disappearance violates the right to personal integrity, because the mere fact of
prolonged isolation and coercive solitary confinement represents cruel and inhuman
treatment contrary to paragraphs 1 and 2 of Article 5 of the Convention; hence it is evident
that, in a forced disappearance, every dimension of the personal integrity of the victim is
violated.215
204. In any event, the Court has established that submitting those detained to official law
enforcement units, State agents, or private individuals acting with their acquiescence or
tolerance, who commit acts of torture and murder with impunity is, in itself, a breach of the
obligation to prevent violations of the rights to personal integrity and to life, even if it is not
possible to prove such violations in the specific case. 216 These circumstances entail a
violation of Articles 5(1) and 5(2) of the American Convention
205. Regarding Article 4 of the American Convention, the Court has considered that,
owing to the very nature of forced disappearance, the victims are in an aggravated situation
of vulnerability, which gives rise to the risk that different rights will be violated, including
the right to life. In addition, the Court has established that forced disappearance has
frequently included the execution of those detained, in secret and without a trial, followed
by the concealment of the corpse in order to erase any material trace of the crime and to
procure the impunity of those who committed it, which signifies a violation of the right to
life, recognized in Article 4 of the Convention.217 Indeed, the Court has verified that this was
the practice during the internal armed conflict in Guatemala.218
206. The Court observes that different reports of government and non-governmental
organizations that have studied the Diario Militar have determined that the annotation of
the number 300 in the Diario Militar means that the person against whose name the number
appeared was executed (supra para. 61). Thus, the Diario Militar records the execution of
17 of the 26 victims who were disappeared in this case. 219 This confirms the presumption of
the violation of the right to life mentioned above, and, consequently, the violation of Article
4(1) of the American Convention, in relation to Article 1(1) of this instrument.
207. The Court cannot fail to mention that, in cases of forced disappearance where there
is evidence that the victim has died, the determination of whether this phenomenon has
been constituted and its cessation, if applicable, necessarily entails finding the remains and
establishing, as validly as possible, the identity of the individual to whom the remains that
held before the Inter-American Commission on October 12, 2007, annex 2 to the merits report, available at:
http://www.oas.org/es/IACHR/audiencias/Hearings.aspx?Lang=En&Session=13.
215
Cf. Case of Velásquez Rodríguez v. Honduras. Merits, supra, para. 187, and Case of the Río Negro
Massacres v. Guatemala, supra, para. 116.
216
Cf. Case of Velásquez Rodríguez v. Honduras. Merits, supra, para. 175, and Case of the Río Negro
Massacres v. Guatemala, supra, para. 117.
217
Cf. Case of Velásquez Rodríguez v. Honduras. Merits, supra, para. 157, and Case of González Medina and
family members v. Dominican Republic, supra, para. 185.
218
Cf. CEH, supra, volume II, pp. 241, 415, 421 and 423, paras. 2068, 2082, 2083 and 2087, and Case of
Molina Theissen v. Guatemala. Merits. Judgment of May 4, 2004. Series C No. 106, para. 40.4.
219
The 17 persons that were executed according to the Diario Militar were: Orencio Sosa Calderón, Oscar
Eduardo Barillas Barrientos, José Porfirio Hernández Bonilla, Octavio René Guzmán Castañeda, Alvaro Zacarías
Calvo Pérez, Amancio Samuel Villatoro, Manuel Ismael Salanic Chiguil, Carlos Guillermo Ramírez Gálvez, Sergio
Saúl Linares Morales, Lesbia Lucrecia García Escobar, Otto René Estrada Illescas, Rubén Amílcar Farfán, Sergio
Leonel Alvarado Arévalo, Alfonso Alvarado Palencia, Zoilo Canales Salazar, Félix Estrada Mejía and Crescencio
Gómez López. Cf. Diario Militar, supra, folios 360, 364, 367, 368, 371, 372, 374, 377, 391, 396, 397, 398 and 404.
- 69 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents