rise to the presumption of harm to the mental and moral integrity of the next of kin.332 In
previous cases, the Court has established that this presumption is established juris tantum
with regard to mothers and fathers, daughters and sons, and spouses and permanent
companions, provided that it accords with the particular circumstances of the case.333 The
Court considers that, in the context of a forced disappearance, this presumption is also
applicable to the sisters and brothers of the disappeared victims, unless the contrary is
revealed by the specific circumstances of the case. Thus, and taking into account the
acknowledgment of responsibility made by the State, the Court presumes the violation of
the right to personal integrity of the next of kin of the 26 disappeared victims.
287. In addition, the Court notes that two of the children of those who disappeared were
not yet born when their fathers were disappeared.334 In this regard, as it has in other
cases335 and taking into consideration the terms of the State’s acknowledgement of
responsibility, the Court considers that they also suffered a violation of their mental and
moral integrity, because the fact that they had to live in an environment of suffering and
uncertainty owing to the failure to determine the whereabouts of the disappeared victims
prejudiced the integrity of the children who were born and lived in this situation.
288. The testimonial statements, as well as the reports on the psychosocial impact on the
families of the disappeared victims, together with other documents in the case file, reveal
that, in this case, the personal integrity of the next of kin was affected in one way or
another, by one or several of the following circumstances:336 (i) they have been involved in
332
Cf. Case of Valle Jaramillo et al. v. Colombia, supra, para. 119, and Case of González Medina and family
members v. Dominican Republic, supra, para. 270.
333
Cf. Case of Blake v. Guatemala. Merits, supra, para. 114, and Case of González Medina and family
members v. Dominican Republic, supra, para. 270.
334
According to the information provided to the Court, the children who were not yet born at the time of the
disappearance of their fathers are: Sergio Alfonso Linares Figueroa, son of Sergio Saúl Linares Morales and Luis
Moisés Peñate Munguía, son of Luis Rolando Peñate Lima. Cf. Certified copy of the entry of the neighborhood
identity card of Sergio Alfonso Linares Figueroa of July 27, 2006 (file of annexes presented by the State with its
brief of October 17, 2008, tome III, folios 7293 and 7294), and Affidavit made by Ana Dolores Munguía Sosa and
Luis Moisés Peñate Munguía on August 2, 2006 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome III, annex 151, folios
1139 and 1141).
335
Cf. Case of Contreras et al. v. El Salvador, supra, para. 122.
336
Cf. Expert opinion of Carlos Martín Beristain on the psychosocial impacts and possible measures of
reparation for the victims in the case of the Diario Militar, Guatemala (file of documents received during the public
hearing, folios 13250 to 13285), and Reports of psychosocial impact on the following families: Gudiel Álvarez, Sosa
Calderón, Barillas Barrientos, Hernández Bonilla, Calvo Pérez, Calderón Díaz, Villatoro, Alvarado Palencia, Salanic
Chiguil, Ramírez Gálvez, Linares Morales, Canales Salazar and Canales Godoy, Méndez Calderón, Armira López,
Rodas Andrade, García Escobar, Estrada Mejía, Estrada Illescas, Farfán, Alvarado Arévalo, and Peñate Lima (file of
annexes to the pleadings and motions brief, Annexes B1 to B4 and B6 to B22, folios 12260 to 12290 and 12297 to
12417). See also, inter alia: affidavit made by Florentín Gudiel Ramos on October 11, 2004 (file of annexes to the
merits report, tome I, annex 14, folio 417); testimony of Makrina Gudiel Álvarez filmed and authenticated on March
25, 2008 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome I, annex 16, folio 420); testimony of Laurenta Marina Sosa
Calderón filmed and authenticated on March 24, 2008 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome I, annex 22, folio
495); affidavits of Bertha Fely Barrientos de Barillas, Juan Francisco Barillas Barrientos and Edgar Leonel Barillas
Barrientos of November 22, 2004 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome II, annex 30, folio 567); testimony of
Juan Francisco Barillas Barrientos filmed and authenticated on March 25, 2008 (file of annexes to the merits report,
tome II, annex 14, folio 573); testimony of Reyna de Jesús Escobar Rodríguez filmed and authenticated on March
28, 2008 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome II, annex 38, folio 595); testimony of Ana Monroy Peralta
filmed and authenticated on March 29, 2008 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome II, annex 40, folio 605);
affidavit made by Sonia Guisela Calderón Revolorio on November 30, 2004 (file of annexes to the merits report,
tome II, annex 40, folio 641); affidavit made by María del Rosario Bran de Villatoro on December 2, 2004 (file of
annexes to the merits report, tome II, annex 47, folio 652); testimony of Sergio Raúl Villatoro Bran filmed and
authenticated on March 28, 2008 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome II, annex 50, folio 671); affidavit
made by María Ofelia Salanic Chiguil on February 9, 2005 (file of annexes to the merits report, tome II, annex 53,
folio 688), and affidavit made by Manuel Ismael Salanic Tuc on April 18, 2012 (file of annexes received during the
public hearing, folio 13033); affidavit made by Jorge Alberto Ramírez Gálvez on February 4, 2005 (file of annexes
- 97 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents