disappearances and the death of Rudy Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz, as well as the alleged
detention and torture of Wendy and Igor Santizo Méndez, and (3) the alleged violations of
the right to personal integrity, movement and residence, protection of the family, rights of
the child, and freedom of association, to the detriment of the next of kin of Rudy Gustavo
Figueroa Muñoz and of the 26 disappeared victims.
VIII-1
FORCED DISAPPEARACE OF THE 26 VICTIMS RECORDED IN THE DIARIO MILITAR
185. In this chapter, the Court will examine the forced disappearances of the 26 victims
whose whereabouts remained unknown when the instant case was submitted, as well as the
alleged violations of freedom of association and expression as a motive for the
disappearances of the said persons.
I. Regarding the forced disappearance of the 26 victims
A) Position of the Inter-American Commission and arguments of the parties
186. The Commission observed that, “in this case, it has been demonstrated that [the 26
victims] were forcibly disappeared by agents of the State of Guatemala,” according to the
entries in the Diario Militar. In addition, it stated that the available testimony, together with
the modus operandi used at the time of the facts, “allow the conclusion to be reached that
the victims were captured arbitrarily and violently” and that torture was used in almost all
the interrogations of those detained clandestinely. The Commission also noted that,
regarding “17 of the 26 victims […], the encoded information in the Diario Militar indicates
that they were allegedly extrajudicially executed.” In this regard, it indicated that “the
Diario Militar suggests that most of the victims were held in clandestine prisons for between
two weeks and two months prior to being executed” and, subsequently, disappeared. In
addition, it observed that despite receiving threats, some family members filed complaints
or applications for habeas corpus, which produced no result. Lastly, the Commission
concluded that “the disappearances in this case “formed part of [a] systematic pattern of
forced disappearances in Guatemala” and therefore “constituted crimes against humanity.”
187. The representatives argued that “the 26 victims of forced disappearance were
captured illegally and arbitrarily, tortured and, to date, their whereabouts are unknown,
[and] their remains have not been found, except in the cases of Amancio Samuel Villatoro
and Sergio Saúl Linares [Morales].” Likewise, they indicated that “most of the victims were
detained […] in clandestine prisons,” which constitutes an aggravating factor of State
responsibility. The representatives also indicated that next of kin were threatened “in order
to obstruct the measures they were taking to find those detained.” They asked the Court to
consider the detention, torture and presumed execution of the victims as a crime against
humanity. In this regard, they indicated that “the Diario Militar is convincing proof that the
State of Guatemala systematically attacked the civilian population” and reveals, together
with the other evidence, that “State intelligence agencies designed, planned and
implemented a counterinsurgency policy based on the National Security Doctrine.” In
addition, they indicated that the appearance of the remains of Sergio Saúl Linares Morales
and Amancio Samuel Villatoro reveals “the coordination among State agencies to carry out
and conceal the disappearances.” They also emphasized that the use of clandestine graves
in these two cases denotes the intent to conceal the evidence.
188. The State indicated that “the appearance of the [Diario Militar] reveals that the cases
of forced disappearance that are the subject-matter of [this case], were committed by State
- 62 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents