Torture, to the detriment of the next of kin of the 26 disappeared victims and of Rudy Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz, as well as the alleged violations of the obligation to guarantee the rights recognized in Articles 3, 4, 5 and 7 of the American Convention to the detriment of the 26 disappeared victims and Rudy Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz, and (ii) the alleged failure to investigate other presumed violations perpetrated against some family members of the disappeared victims, including Wendy Santizo Méndez. 224. The Court recalls that, based on its competence ratione temporis, it can only rule on the facts relating to the investigations that occurred after March 9, 1987 (supra paras. 30 and 31). The facts that occurred before that date will only be taken into account as background information in the case, and this Court does not have competence to determine legal consequences in relation to the alleged international responsibility. I. Obligation to investigate the forced disappearances of the 26 disappeared victims and the death of Rudy Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz A. Position of the Inter-American Commission and arguments of the parties 225. The Commission indicated that “impunity subsists” in this case. It noted that, “even when the families of the disappeared victims in this case took the risk of formally reporting the incidents, the judicial authorities lacked the will or the real ability to perform their duty.” It stated that Decree No. 8-86 “contributed to the impunity” of the facts, and thus this norm violated Article 2 of the Convention until its repeal in December 1997. Regarding the investigations opened following the appearance of the Diario Militar, it indicated that the process has been “plagued by formalities and characterized by the refusal of the judicial authorities to diligently follow logical lines of investigation [deriving from the Diario Militar itself], thus condemning the process to the ineffectiveness that has existed to date.” The Commission stressed that the Public Prosecution Service, only “exceptionally” had requested military archives or received the statement of a former member of the Armed Forces, and had not inspected military premises. It also observed “a clear lack of collaboration by the Ministry of Defense.” In addition, the Commission underlined that the State had not conducted an investigation within a reasonable time. Lastly, and in particular with regard to the investigation of the death of Rudy Gustavo Figueroa Muñoz, the Commission considered that the State had not made a serious and real effort to investigate it, either at the time it occurred, or following the publication of the Diario Militar. 226. The representatives indicated that the alleged violations in this case “have remained in absolute impunity.” First, they pointed out that, when the victims were detained, the situation in the country ensured the ineffectiveness of the remedy of habeas corpus and prevented effective access to the remedy; while the authorities did not undertake any investigative measures to determine the identity of those responsible or the whereabouts of the victims prior to 1999. Second, they argued that, from 1986 to 1997, the amnesty laws made it impossible to investigate and prosecute those responsible. Third, they indicated that the criminal investigation opened in 1999 has been flawed, owing to: (i) lack of procedural activity for prolonged periods; (ii) failure to construct hypotheses taking into account the available evidence; (iii) serious omissions in following up on logical lines of investigation, and (iv) lack of collaboration of the authorities, particularly the Ministry of Defense. Fourth, have the right to an impartial examination of his case. Likewise, if there is an accusation or well-grounded reason to believe that an act of torture has been committed within their jurisdiction, the States Parties shall guarantee that their respective authorities will proceed properly and immediately to conduct an investigation into the case and to initiate, whenever appropriate, the corresponding criminal process. After all the domestic legal procedures of the respective State and the corresponding appeals have been exhausted, the case may be submitted to the international fora whose competence has been recognized by that State.” - 76 -

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents