254. In addition, the Historical Archive of the National Police has contributed specific and
objective data to the investigation concerning the forced disappearances of the victims
recorded in the Diario Militar that have been brought to the attention of the Public
Prosecution Service. For example, the Court observes that, the documents found in the
Historical Archive of the National Police have revealed, inter alia, information on two
individuals potentially involved in the capture of Luz Haydée Méndez Calderón (supra para.
112). However, there is no evidence that any measure was taken as a result of this
information. The Court takes note of what was indicated by the prosecutor during the
hearing and in the report of the Public Prosecution Service to the effect that the information
in the Historical Archive of the National Police is being examined, but notes that the first
part of this information was provided to the Public Prosecution Service more than three
years ago.289
255. The Court also observes that the next of kin of several of the disappeared victims
also witnessed the capture of their loved ones, and have provided information in this regard
to the case file.290 Similarly, it notes that the National Police provided information on the
identity of senior officials of this institution at the time the disappearances started, and that
the statement of the then Director of the National Police has been received (supra para.
179). However, the evidence submitted to the Court does not reveal whether any measure
or action was taken with regard to this information, even though it relates to objective
evidence contained in the case file that could help elucidate the facts.
256. The Court considers that the failure to follow up on and to consider all these
elements, and others in the case file, constitute serious omissions in the investigation. In
particular, it concludes that the absence of a joint and interrelated study of the Diario
Militar, the Historical Archive of the National Police, and the statements of the victims'
families, among other matters, have led to the absence of significant progress in the
investigation, which has resulted in its ineffectiveness and the consequent failure to identify
and punish those who, in different ways, may have participated in the said violations. The
Court emphasizes that the abundant documentary evidence (the Diario Militar and Historical
Archive of the National Police) in the case file has appeared by accident or through unofficial
channels, and thus it has not been the result of a serious and diligent investigation.
Nevertheless, and even given this type of evidence, the competent authorities have
continued not to adopt the necessary measures to take advantage of the information
contained in this evidence or to follow up on the indications that emerge from it. The Court
considered that it has been proved that the lack of collaboration of the Ministry of Defense
has seriously obstructed the progress of the investigations. In addition, it notes that,
according to recent information forwarded by Public Prosecution Service, an investigation
line and strategy that is consistent with the existence of the Diario Militar and the
information contained in it is finally being adopted, and some investigative activity by the
289
In May 2009, la Peace Secretariat forwarded the Public Prosecution Service a publication “La autenticidad
del Diario Militar, a la luz de los documentos históricos of the National Police,” together with the documents of the
Historical Archive of the National Police related to the cases of the Diario Militar. Cf. Bulletin 04-09 of the Peace
Secretariat of July 2009 (file of annexes to the pleadings and motions brief, tome II, annex A17, folio 10144). Also,
according to the representatives, in June 2010, other documents found in the Historical Archive of the National
Police up until that time on the cases recorded in the Diario Militar had been handed over to the Public Prosecution
Service. However, the Court was not provided with any evidence in this regard. Cf. Pleadings and motions brief,
tome II, folio 558.
290
For example, Manuel Ismael Salanic Chiguil’s father stated that some of the armed men who took part in
his son’s detention wore BROE uniform; while Wendy Santizo Méndez, Luz Haydée Méndez Calderón’s daughter,
has testified on the location of the National Police station where her mother was taken initially (supra paras. 95 and
114). In this regard, no information has been provided to the Court from which activities to follow up on this
information can be inferred..
- 86 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents