262. The Court has usually considered the following elements to determine the
reasonableness of the time: (a) the complexity of the matter; (b) the procedural activity of
the interested party; (c) the conduct of the judicial authorities, and (d) the effects on the
legal situation of the person involved in the proceedings. However, in this case, the Court
has verified that, from the date of the acceptance of the Court’s jurisdiction until today, 25
years and 8 months have elapsed,300 as well as 13 years and 6 months since the
appearance of the Diario Militar (supra para. 59), during which the investigation of the facts
of this case has not advanced beyond the initial phase of the investigation before the Public
Prosecution Service. The Court emphasizes that, initially, the State failed to comply with its
obligation to open the corresponding investigations ex officio; while, during a second stage,
the conduct of the authorities in charge of the investigation by the Public Prosecution
Service has lacked due diligence in the implementation of these investigations (supra paras.
240 to 260). The Court also stresses that the case file of the investigation before the Public
Prosecution Service301 reveals several periods of procedural inactivity. Consequently, the
Court considers that it is unnecessary to analyze the above-mentioned criteria, because it is
evident that the time that has passed is far in excess of the time that could be considered
reasonable for the State to investigate the facts of this case, especially when it is considered
that the time required to individualize and identify those responsible and the processing of
the different stages of the criminal proceedings until a final judgment is obtained must be
added to this. This absence of investigation for such a long period constitutes a flagrant
denial of justice and a violation of the right of access to justice of the victims.
5. Alleged violation of the obligation to adopt domestic legal provisions
263. The Court observes that both the Commission and the representatives alleged the
violation of Article 2 of the American Convention, because, inter alia, the situation of
“generalized impunity” in this case is due in part to the dissuasive effect of the National
Reconciliation Act on the investigation of crimes committed during the internal armed
conflict, as well as to the “structural weaknesses of the Guatemalan administration of justice
that affect this case.” The State acknowledged its “total” responsibility for the alleged
violation of Article 2 of the Convention (supra para. 17(b)(4)), without specifying the
reasons why it made this acknowledgement
264. In particular, regarding the 1996 National Reconciliation Law, the Court notes that
this law has not been applied to the facts of this case, which was expressly indicated by the
representatives and the Commission. The Court finds that it is not incumbent on it to make
a ruling on or an analysis of this law, because the purpose of the Court’s contentious
competence is not to review domestic legislation in the abstract.302 In addition, with regard
to considering that the impunity in this case constitutes a violation of Article 2 of the
Convention, the Court finds that it has not been provided with the elements required to
verify that the obstacles to the elucidation of the facts in this case constitute a failure to
comply with the State’s general obligation established in the said Article 2.
265. Nevertheless, the Court finds that, more than 29 years after the first disappearances
in this case occurred, the facts are clearly framed in a systematic pattern of denial of justice
300
began.
To date, from 27 years and 9 months to 29 years have elapsed since the disappearances in this case
301
The Court recalls that, owing to the State’s request for confidentiality, the updated file of the investigation
by the Public Prosecution Service is not part of the body of evidence in this case (supra para. 11). Consequently,
the analysis of the State’s obligations is made based on the copy of the case file up until 2008, which was
forwarded to the Inter-American Commission.
302
Cf. Case of Genie Lacayo v. Nicaragua. Preliminary objections. Judgment of January 27, 1995. Series C
No. 21, para. 50, and Case of Contreras et al. v. El Salvador, supra, para. 172.
- 89 -
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents